>> I will make the change. I'll also remind the EAI group that >> there have been a couple of objections to the >> 5322upd-from-group spec, which I have to address. I might do >> that by scoping it down a bit with some "SHOULD NOT use" sort >> of language to address those concerns. Have to review them >> and see. > > My suggestion is to say something like the following: ... > That could be either in Security Considerations or a separate > section. You could even do something radical and incorporate it > as a section called "Applicability" and use the words "LIMITED > USE" (and, since no one seems to remember, a citation of RFC > 2026 Section 3.3). I have just posted drft-leiba-5322upd-from-group-04: http://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-leiba-5322upd-from-group/ That changes the definition of Sender as well as From, and also adds a new "Applicability Statement" section that has an edited version of John's suggested text. I like the result, and I hope others do as well. I will post something to the 5322upd-from-group thread, asking that those who had objected look at the new text and see if they're happy (or at least somewhat happier) with it. Barry