>>>>> "Alexey" == Alexey Melnikov <alexey.melnikov@xxxxxxxxx> writes:
Alexey> Sam Hartman wrote:
>>>>>>> "Jiankang" == Jiankang YAO <yaojk@xxxxxxxx> writes:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
Jiankang> If there are many things we must do, we(WGs) normally
Jiankang> prioritize the things. sometimes, the easier one first;
Jiankang> sometimes, the difficult one first.
>> Sure. That's fine for the WG to do. I don't think it is good to
>> do in the charter without some fairness criteria. All items
>> brought up by the time external review of the charter concluded
>> seems like a reasonable fairness criteria. Putting the cutoff
>> before that seems unreasonable.
>>
>> Obviously, the WG can internally prioritize (and change its
>> priorities) within its normal administrative processes.
>>
Jiankang> If peter's list is not ok for you, could you kindly give
Jiankang> us your list?
>>
>> The list in the charter plus:
>>
>> 1) Considering Kerberos implications for SASLPREP revisions
>>
>>
Alexey> Sam, I think this is granted. I don't think this needs to be
Alexey> written into the charter, especially considering that there
Alexey> is a good deal of overlap between people active in Kerberos
Alexey> and SASL WGs.
I'm totally happy with that interpretation.
>> 2) Considering RFC 4282.
>>
>>
Alexey> Do you consider RFC 4282 to be a stringprep profile? My
Alexey> quick scan of the document (in particular Section 2.4) is
Alexey> not conclusive.
It's my read that section 2.4 invokes all of toascii from IDNA 2003,
which definitely implies stringprep under the covers. However, I think
the spec is kind of broken both for IDNA2003 and IDNA2008; if you take a
look at the proposed erata aspects of the AAA community agree. The
solution is probably not going to be a stringprep profile, although the
solution is probably not going to be any more complicated than something
like XMPP's solution. However, I definitely think the AAA community
needs to have some internationalization experts to talk to in order to
have a chance of success.
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf