John,
I think we have reached agreement that the
Nomcom should be able to suppress names when they
conclude that is desirable --that they "may" publish
lists of names if they decide to do so. But the text of
the document actually doesn't make that clear. It
provides that a list can be published, that updated list
can be published if the Nomcom considers that desirable,
and that there should be no ringers. It does not
explicitly provide for publishing a list that omits some
willing candidates, no matter what the reason.
I agree that we should allow this.
Jari
P.S. For the other issues in your mail -- FWIW, I believe fairly
strongly that we should make the specific changes proposed in this
document, as opposed to starting a more general redesign.
_______________________________________________
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf