On 2007-10-03 11:49, Russ Housley wrote:
The Secretariat tells me that Spammers are responding to TDMA queries so
that their mail goes through. They have made the suggestion that we
clear the list of people once per year. This would mean that a
legitimate user of a list that uses TDMA would get a TDMA query once a
year if they are not subscribed to any ietf.org mail list. There is no
TDMA query for people who are on at least one ietf.org mail list.
Here is the info that I have:
> Russ wants to know how many people have responded to the TMDA
> challenge but are not on any IETF mailing list.
1025 mail addresses have "confirmed" their address. I would bet that
at least 20% of the confirmed are spam addresses (or autoconfirmed
addresses)
A little history... I manually scanned the TMDA white list about
a year ago, or rather I scanned the ~700 addresses that had then
confirmed themselves. I didn't keep the relevant files on grounds
of privacy protection, but I recall that around 30 of the addresses
were self-evidently spammers that we removed manually; there were quite
a lot that were self-evidently genuine. However, there were a large
number which just couldn't be classified by inspection. I can easily
believe the 20% estimate.
Speaking personally, I think annual reconfirmation is quite reasonable.
The message sent to the user should make it clear that it is an
annual process.
Brian
_______________________________________________
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf