My apologies in advance for posting in this thread.
There was, to recall history, no consensus in newtrk for any particular
choice among the various options for simplifying the 3 stage process.
So the IESG never saw or responded to any proposal in that area.
My understanding (as author of three of the proposals) was that for most of
the time newtrk was in existence, the working group's attention was focused
on ISDs as a way of avoiding the need to tackle the 3 stage process. So I'm
not sure there was even a call for consensus on adopting any of the
proposals as a working group document.
FWIW.
Spencer
_______________________________________________
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf