>>>>> "Scott" == Scott Bradner <sob@xxxxxxxxxxx> writes: Scott> ps - I'm not sure that its all that useful to be able to Scott> appeal/review awards if they can not be overturned - Scott> apealing or reviewing the process that was followed is fine Scott> but appealling the actual award seems broken I disagree. Reviewing a specific decision in an operational context to determine whether the right decision was made can be a useful feedback step in a control loop of a system. I've found this to be true whether systems are technical or manigerial. --Sam _______________________________________________ Ietf@xxxxxxxx https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf