Brian's response seems reasonable to me.
John
------------------- Original message -------------------
Subject: Re: Transparency/Openness of the IAOC
From: "Brian E Carpenter" <brc@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Time: 12/08/2004 3:53 pm
Margaret Wasserman wrote:
>
> Hi All,
>
> In reviewing the IASA BCP draft, I noticed that there are no specific
> requirements regarding the level of transparency or openness expected
> from the IAOC. IMO, we should be careful to start this activity with a
> well-established understanding regarding the level of transparency and
> openness that we expect.
>
> Do we expect the IAOC to keep minutes of their meetings and post them
> publicly (unless there is a specific reason not to post a certain
> section)? Specific reasons might include: personnel issue and/or
> sensitive negotiation-position-related information.
yes
>
> Do we expect the IAOC mailing list archives to be publicly available?
no, that would prevent any email on sensitive contractual or personnel
issues
>
> Should the IAOC maintain a web site that lists its members and their
> e-mail addresses?
on ietf.org
>
> Should the same web site also include a record of all written/legal
> correspondence received by or sent by the IAOC (with sections removed if
> absolutely necessary for confidentiality)?
I think that is an onerous requirement
>
> Should all of the official IAOC decisions be announced publicly?
yes, ietf-announce
> And/or
> do we expect a regular (monthly?) report on IAOC activities?
I'd say the mandatory frequency should be per IETF meeting
>
> If we think that it is reasonable to require any of these things, which
> ones should apply to the IASA TT that we just formed?
exactly the same ones
IMHO
Brian
_______________________________________________
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf
_______________________________________________
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf