Hi, On Nov 10, 2022, at 10:49, Samuel Weiler <weiler@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > I'm asking if the penalty imposed by a PR action also applies to other-than-email IETF communications, e.g. may a WG chair block someone already subject to a PR action from posting in a Github repository? not based on BCP83, in my understanding of the process. That said, the underlying principle here - in my mind - is that the community has granted certain moderation privileges to WG chairs and similar roles, and the community hence has the expectation that they should apply to all of the contribution channels a given group is utilizing. So if a WG is using - for example - GitHub issues, I would assume that WG expects its chairs to moderate that contribution channel alongside any others. That principle is AFAIK not explicitly written down, and so challenging such a moderation action for a contribution channel that isn't the mailing list would need to happen along the appeals path. That is somewhat dissatisfying in terms of the associated process overhead, but until we have consensus on a different moderation approach, this approach should serve in the interim. Thanks, Lars
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: Message signed with OpenPGP
