A clarifying question: be “rerun the selection process” you mean starting from announcing random seeds. Those seeds must not be currently available of course. Second question: “remaining eligible candidates.” Ah, the ambiguities of English. Do you mean to remove those picked? Obviously, I have to treat all volunteers who would be a third member of the same company as ineligible. Do I remove
all those people and publish a new list? If so, is that list subject to a challenge wait? It must be, to make sure I didn’t delete someone incorrectly. Suppose someone from one of the companies with two representatives steps down, do I not remove them? Suppose
I remove them and then they step down, do I repeat the add/post/challenge cycle? That leads me to think that removing “third member” is a bad idea. But then I wonder about the inconsistency with removing already-picked people. Gaming seems to be still possible. FWIW, I find historical precedent, historical vagueness in English, and Don Eastlake’s posting [1] compelling. [1] https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/ietf/V37bqFz8ANGAgeqB0t2_vs1qlJc/ |
