On 11/1/21 10:08 AM, Miles Fidelman wrote:
And the goal should be to prevent IETF perform meaninglessNow THIS seems like a living example of something that is both unprofessional AND uncivil.
engineering such as development of stupid protocols, including
but not limited to, IPv6 and LISP.
I don't agree with that opinion of IPv6. (I'll reserve opinion
about LISP - I didn't like what it was when originally proposed,
but I haven't tried to evaluate what it ended up being.)
But people absolutely should be free to criticize IETF work, even
work that some people are pleased with. Even if they say that
the work is useless, meaningless, or harmful.
(it might help, though, if the criticism has some informative
detail to it, so that readers can understand why it's being
criticized.)
Keith
