Hiya, On 26/06/2021 00:03, Michael StJohns wrote:
Hi - No challenges, but an observation or two. There are only 6 companies with more than two volunteers:Cisco - 7Â (6.3% of the pool, 47% chance of having at least one member, 12.6% of having 2). Juniper - 9 (8% of the pool, 57% chance of having at least one member, 18.9% of having 2)Ericsson - 4 (3.6%, 30.5%, 4.7%) ZTE - 3 (2.7%, 23.8%, 2.8%) Akamai - 3 (2.7%, 23.8%, 2.8%) Huawei/Futurewei - 41 (36.6, 99%, 93%)
Yeah. The last line above smacks of gaming a system within the rules. I thought more companies did that TBH;-( One other observation: I expected the "click here" in the tracker to increase the size of the pool, but it doesn't seem to have had that effect. Maybe it needs another year though, as it was announced fairly close to the deadline. Cheers, S.
A SWAG against that numbers suggests a Nomcom with 2 members from Huawai/Futurewei, 1-2 members from Cisco and Juniper (not each, total) and a 60% chance of having at least 1 member from one of Ericsson, Akamai or ZTE.2 person companies represent (each) 1.8% of the pool, have a 16.5% chance of having at least one member, and have a 1.3% chance of having two.The numbers are not exact because of the organizational limit factor - e.g. individuals and 2 party companies (totalling 112-67 or 45) are roughly competing for the slots (4-6 slots at a guess) not won by these 5, which gives those folk individually a 8.3% to 11.9% chance of selection depending on the number of slots available.For an illustration of what affect the organizational limits have on the final composition of the Nomcom, without the limits, or with higher ones, Huawei/Futurewei would have a 77% chance of 3 or more members, a 53% chance of 4 or more members and a 28.5% chance of 5 or more.  That suggests that due to the limits, in this selection process at least 2 or more volunteers will be selected randomly and discarded due to there already being 2 selectees from that group.Yours statistically, Mike On 6/25/2021 4:46 PM, NomCom Chair 2021 wrote:This is a preliminary list of 112 qualified volunteers for NomCom 2021-2022.All have been qualified by using the Datatracker as qualified for the position of votingmember of NomCom per RFC 8989.We now enter the challenge period, which lasts until the following deadline:Monday, July 5, 2021 at 23:59 UTC (Deadline for raising issues on the qualified volunteers list)If anyone thinks that a name on the numbered list below is NOT qualified for somereason, please send me email before this deadline at: nomcom-chair-2021 at ietf dot orgThe next steps are listed on https://datatracker.ietf.org/nomcom/2021/ (e.g., I will announcerandom seed selections for the RFC 3797 process shortly). The preliminary qualified volunteers are: Num Last Name First Name Affiliation =================================================================== 1 Aelmans Melchior Juniper Networks 2 Bagdonas Ignas Equinix 3 Banks Sarah Corelight, Inc. 4 Barnes Mary Independent 5 Beeram Vishnu Juniper Networks6 Benamar Nabil Moulay Ismail University of Meknes, Morocco7 Bertola Vittorio Open-Xchange8 Bishop Mike Akamai Technologies9 Bonica Ron Juniper Networks 10 Box Chris BT 11 Burdet LucAndré Cisco12 Bush Randy IIJ Research Lab & Arrcus Inc13 Busi Italo Huawei 14 Chen Mach Huawei 15 Chen Huaimo Futurewei 16 Cheng Weiqiang China Mobile 17 Ciavaglia Laurent Rakuten 18 Clemm Alexander Futurewei 19 Dhody Dhruv Huawei20 Dong Jie Huawei Technologies21 Drake John Juniper Networks22 Eastlake Donald Futurewei Technologies, Inc23 Eckel Charles Cisco Systems 24 Eckert Toerless Futurewei USA 25 Enghardt Theresa Netflix 26 Fan Dawei Huawei27 Farrell Stephen Trinity College Dublin 28 Fioccola Giuseppe Huawei Technologies29 Fomin Sergey Nokia 30 Fossati Thomas Arm 31 Geng Xuesong Huawei 32 Gondwana Bron Fastmail Pty Ltd 33 Gu Yunan Huawei 34 Gundavelli Sri Cisco 35 Haas Jeffrey Juniper Networks 36 Haddad Wassim Ericsson37 Hallam-Baker Phillip Threshold Secrets LLC38 Harrison Tom APNIC 39 Hegde Shraddha Juniper Networks40 Heitz Jakob Cisco Systems, Inc.41 Hopps Christian LabN Consulting42 Housley Russ Vigil Security, LLC 43 Huitema Christian Private Octopus Inc.44 Iannone Luigi Huawei 45 Jimenez Jaime Ericsson 46 Lear Eliot Cisco Systems47 Leiba Barry Futurewei Technologies48 Lemon Ted Apple 49 Li Cheng Huawei50 Li Richard Futurewei Technologies, Inc.51 Li Yizhou Huawei52 Lin Yi Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. 53 Liu Bing Huawei Technologies Co.,Ltd. 54 Lou Zhe Huawei Technologies Duesseldorf GmbH55 Maisonneuve Julien Nokia 56 Makhijani Kiran Futurewei 57 Mankin Allison Salesforce 58 Masinter Larry Interlisp.org 59 Mattsson John Ericsson 60 McManus Patrick Fastly 61 Michaelson George APNIC 62 Min Xiao ZTE Corporation 63 Mishra Sanjay Verizon 64 Mizrahi Tal Huawei 65 Moore Keith Network Heretics 66 Nottingham Mark Fastly67 Paine Kirsty UK National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC)68 Pan Wei Huawei69 Peng Shuping Huawei Technologies Co.,Ltd. 70 Petit-Huguenin Marc Impedance Mismatch LLC 71 Pillay-Esnault Padma Independent, Amazon 72 Qu Yingzhen Futurewei Technologies Inc.73 Reid Jim rtfm llp 74 Rescorla Eric Mozilla75 Resnick Pete Episteme Technology Consulting LLC 76 Richardson Michael Sandelman Software Works 77 Romano Simon University of Napoli Federico II 78 Rose Kyle Akamai Technologies, Inc.79 Saad Tarek Juniper Networks 80 Salz Rich Akamai 81 Sangli Srihari Juniper Networks 82 Schwartz Benjamin Google LLC 83 Song Haoyu Futurewei84 StJohns Michael NthPermutation Security85 Thubert Pascal Cisco Systems 86 Trøan Ole cisco 87 Tschofenig Hannes Arm 88 Velvindron Loganaden cyberstorm.mu89 Volpato Paolo Huawei Technologies90 Wang Haibo Huawei 91 Wang Yali Huawei 92 Wei Yuehua ZTE Corporation 93 Weiler Samuel W3C/MIT 94 Westerlund Magnus Ericsson 95 Winters Timothy QA Cafe96 Woolf Suzanne Public Interest Registry (.ORG) 97 Wu Bo Huawei Technologies Co.,Ltd. 98 Xiao XiPeng Huawei Technologies 99 Xie Jingrong Huawei Technologies100 Xingjian He huawei 101 Yan Gang Huawei102 Yang Fan Huawei Technologies Co.,Ltd.103 Yu Yolanda Huawei 104 Zhang Lixia UCLA 105 Zhang Zheng ZTE 106 Zhang Zhaohui Juniper 107 Zhao Shuai Tencent 108 Zheng Guangying Huawei109 Zheng Haomian Huawei Technologies110 Zhou Tianran Huawei 111 Zhuang Shunwan Huawei112 江元龙 Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.
Attachment:
OpenPGP_0x5AB2FAF17B172BEA.asc
Description: OpenPGP public key
Attachment:
OpenPGP_signature
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
