On May 8, 2021 at 6:53:46 PM, Bob Hinden wrote: Bob: Hi! ... > I think something is needed where the reported problem can be accepted, but > the fix can be rejected. Perhaps some new states, or a change to how the > Errata system works. You're right, *without proper explanation*, there is no explicit state that indicates a valid problem and an invalid solution. Hold for Document Update is the closest as further discussion is obviously needed. However, even with a proper explanation, it may still be confusing whether the proposed solution is valid or not. One of the issues is that there is a single notes field that is used by both the submitter and the verifier. Also, these notes appear *after* the problem/solution have been described, making it harder to find relevant comments. Changing how the errata system works requires a wider discussion of course -- beyond what the current statement is intended for. Thanks! Alvaro.
