Videoconferencing software - Mirial vs. PacPhone - strange behaviour in PrefixAuth on Mirial's part

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



I am testing Mirial Softphone, to use it instead of (or alongside) PacPhone
 
(btw does anyone know about good h.323 videoconferencing software -not necesaarely free- which does not have complex licencing systems and which works as "pure" H.323 client?)

But I get a strange behaviour when using Mirial.

Even tho Mirial registers on GnuGk fine (using the same H323 number and the same IP as PacPhone), Prefix Auth on GnuGk does not work correctly and calls are denied.

These are the logs when client (number 41100) tries to make a call to number 491 (an MCU room).

-----PacPhone 2.3.1---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 5          job.cxx(190) JOB Starting Job ARQ at Worker thread 1480
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 1       RasSrv.cxx(354) RAS ARQ Received from 10.1.10.12:5000
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 5       gkauth.cxx(2079) GKAUTH Prefix auth rule 'allow alias:^411' matched
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 4       gkauth.cxx(2281) GKAUTH PrefixAuth rule matched and accepted destination prefix '491' for alias '491'
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 3       gkauth.cxx(1030) GKAUTH PrefixAuth ARQ check ok
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 3       RasSrv.cxx(2661) GK ARQ will request bandwith of 50000
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 5        Routing.h(184) ROUTING Checking policy Explicit for the request ARQ 5050
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 5        Routing.h(184) ROUTING Checking policy Internal for the request ARQ 5050
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 2       RasTbl.cxx(1199) RASTBL Gateway 8718_endp matched by prefix 49, priority: 1
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 4       RasTbl.cxx(1636) RASTBL Prefix match for gateways: 10.1.10.11:1720
2010/07/22 09:36:46.453 5        Routing.h(190) ROUTING Policy Internal applied to the request ARQ 5050
2010/07/22 09:36:46.468 2       RasTbl.cxx(3382) CallTable::Insert(CALL) Call No. 200, total sessions : 1
-----Mirial 7.0.5---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 5          job.cxx(190) JOB Starting Job ARQ at Worker thread 1480
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 1       RasSrv.cxx(354) RAS ARQ Received from 10.1.10.12:1719
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 4       gkauth.cxx(2298) GKAUTH PrefixAuth rule matched and  could not reject or accept destination prefix '491' for alias '491'
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 4       gkauth.cxx(2298) GKAUTH PrefixAuth rule matched and  could not reject or accept destination prefix '4' for alias '491'
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 4       gkauth.cxx(2314) GKAUTH PrefixAuth could not reject or accept the request
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 5        gksql.cxx(387) SQLAuth Executing query: SELECT action FROM regole WHERE (numero_chiamato='491' AND numero_chiamante='41100') OR 'angelucci'='InternalMakeCallEP' ;
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 3      sqlauth.cxx(245) SQLAUTH SQLAuth(ARQ from 10.1.10.12 CRV=17847): query returned no rows
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 3       gkauth.cxx(1035) GKAUTH SQLAuth ARQ check failed
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 2       RasSrv.cxx(394) ARJ|10.1.10.12:1720|491:dialedDigits|41100:dialedDigits=angelucci:h323_ID|false|resourceUnavailable|1f-79-69-3e-d5-01-19-10-8b-5a-02-01-51-12-10-60;
2010/07/22 09:41:57.781 3       RasSrv.cxx(236) RAS Send to 10.1.10.12:1719
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As you can see, PacPhone passes the PrefixAuth rule, while Mirial does not. And i cannot understand why. (Of course the clients are not active simultaneously)

This is ARQ's configuration in Gnugk (version 2.3.2, Build(Jun 29 2010, 14:43:16) Sys(Server 2003 i586 (Model=3 Stepping=4) v5.2.3790))
------------------------------
[Gatekeeper::Auth]
PrefixAuth=alternative;ARQ
SQLAuth=sufficient;ARQ

[PrefixAuth]
491=allow alias:^411
8=allow alias:^4
3=allow alias:^41100
2=allow alias:^41100
1=allow alias:^41100
4=allow alias:^41100
9=allow alias:^41100
41100=allow alias:^4
------------------------------

These are the ips
---------------------------------
Terminal IP: 10.1.10.12
Gk IP: 10.1.10.10
MCU IP: 10.1.10.11
---------------------------------
 
In the attachments, the registrationsRequest and registrationConfirm for both clients as retrieved from Gnugk log (the main difference to me seems only that Mirial is sending H323 alias too alongside the dialedDigits information).
 
What's going on? What's that's not working?

Thanks,
pierlu.

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
registrationRequest {
    requestSeqNum = 51702
    protocolIdentifier = 0.0.8.2250.0.6
    discoveryComplete = true
    callSignalAddress = 1 entries {
      [0]=ipAddress {
        ip =  4 octets {
          1a 97 79 3c                                        ..y<
        }
        port = 1720
      }
    }
    rasAddress = 1 entries {
      [0]=ipAddress {
        ip =  4 octets {
          1a 97 79 3c                                        ..y<
        }
        port = 1719
      }
    }
    terminalType = {
      vendor = {
        vendor = {
          t35CountryCode = 89
          t35Extension = 0
          manufacturerCode = 17484
        }
        productId =  16 octets {
          44 79 6c 6f 67 69 63 20  4d 69 72 69 61 6c 00 00   Dylogic Mirial..
        }
        versionId =  8 octets {
          37 2e 30 2e 32 35 00 00                            7.0.25..
        }
      }
      terminal = {
      }
      mc = false
      undefinedNode = false
    }
    terminalAlias = 2 entries {
      [0]=h323_ID  9 characters {
        0061 006e 0067 0065 006c 0075 0063 0063   angelucc
        0069                                      i
      }
      [1]=dialedDigits "41100"
    }
    gatekeeperIdentifier =  6 characters {
      0047 004e 0055 0067 006b 0032             GNUgk2
    }
    endpointVendor = {
      vendor = {
        t35CountryCode = 89
        t35Extension = 0
        manufacturerCode = 17484
      }
      productId =  16 octets {
        44 79 6c 6f 67 69 63 20  4d 69 72 69 61 6c 00 00   Dylogic Mirial..
      }
      versionId =  8 octets {
        37 2e 30 2e 32 35 00 00                            7.0.25..
      }
    }
    keepAlive = false
    willSupplyUUIEs = true
    maintainConnection = false
    supportsAltGK = <<null>>
    usageReportingCapability = {
      nonStandardUsageTypes = 0 entries {
      }
      startTime = <<null>>
      endTime = <<null>>
      terminationCause = <<null>>
    }
    callCreditCapability = {
      canEnforceDurationLimit = true
    }
  }
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
registrationConfirm {
    requestSeqNum = 26662
    protocolIdentifier = 0.0.8.2250.0.6
    nonStandardData = {
      nonStandardIdentifier = h221NonStandard {
        t35CountryCode = 138
        t35Extension = 2
        manufacturerCode = 2
      }
      data =  5 octets {
        4e 6f 4e 41 54                                     NoNAT
      }
    }
    callSignalAddress = 1 entries {
      [0]=ipAddress {
        ip =  4 octets {
          a0 01 a0 a2                                        ..n,
        }
        port = 1721
      }
    }
    terminalAlias = 2 entries {
      [0]=h323_ID  9 characters {
        0061 006e 0067 0065 006c 0075 0063 0063   angelucc
        0069                                      i
      }
      [1]=dialedDigits "41100"
    }
    gatekeeperIdentifier =  6 characters {
      0047 004e 0055 0067 006b 0032             GNUgk2
    }
    endpointIdentifier =  9 characters {
      0038 0037 0037 0039 005f 0065 006e 0064   8779_end
      0070                                      p
    }
    timeToLive = 60
    willRespondToIRR = false
    maintainConnection = false
    serviceControl = 1 entries {
      [0]={
        sessionId = 0
        contents = callCreditServiceControl {
          callStartingPoint = connect <<null>>
        }
        reason = open <<null>>
      }
    }
  }
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
registrationRequest {
    requestSeqNum = 19728
    protocolIdentifier = 0.0.8.2250.0.6
    discoveryComplete = true
    callSignalAddress = 1 entries {
      [0]=ipAddress {
        ip =  4 octets {
          1a 97 79 3c                                        ..y<
        }
        port = 1720
      }
    }
    rasAddress = 1 entries {
      [0]=ipAddress {
        ip =  4 octets {
          1a 97 79 3c                                        ..y<
        }
        port = 5000
      }
    }
    terminalType = {
      vendor = {
        vendor = {
          t35CountryCode = 156
          t35Extension = 0
          manufacturerCode = 1
        }
        productId =  18 octets {
          53 70 72 61 6e 74 6f 20  50 61 63 50 68 6f 6e 65   Spranto PacPhone
          00 00                                              ..
        }
        versionId =  7 octets {
          32 2e 33 2e 31 00 00                               2.3.1..
        }
      }
      terminal = {
      }
      mc = false
      undefinedNode = false
    }
    terminalAlias = 1 entries {
      [0]=dialedDigits "41100"
    }
    gatekeeperIdentifier =  7 characters {
      0047 004e 0055 0067 006b 0032 0000        GNUgk2 
    }
    endpointVendor = {
      vendor = {
        t35CountryCode = 156
        t35Extension = 0
        manufacturerCode = 1
      }
      productId =  18 octets {
        53 70 72 61 6e 74 6f 20  50 61 63 50 68 6f 6e 65   Spranto PacPhone
        00 00                                              ..
      }
      versionId =  7 octets {
        32 2e 33 2e 31 00 00                               2.3.1..
      }
    }
    timeToLive = 2100
    tokens = 1 entries {
      [0]={
        tokenOID = 1.2.840.113548.10.1.2.1
        timeStamp = 1279785517
        challenge =  16 octets {
          e4 33 80 a3 59 cb 85 83  53 dc 3f 98 7d bb 2c 4e   .3..Y...S.?.}.,N
        }
        random = 55
        generalID =  6 characters {
          0034 0031 0031 0030 0030 0000             41100 
        }
      }
    }
    cryptoTokens = 2 entries {
      [0]=nestedcryptoToken cryptoHashedToken {
        tokenOID = 0.0.8.235.0.2.1
        hashedVals = {
          tokenOID = 0.0.8.235.0.2.5
          timeStamp = 1279785517
          random = 422858245
          generalID =  7 characters {
            0047 004e 0055 0067 006b 0032 0000        GNUgk2 
          }
          sendersID =  6 characters {
            0034 0031 0031 0030 0030 0000             41100 
          }
        }
        token = {
          algorithmOID = 0.0.8.235.0.2.6
          paramS = {
          }
          hash = Hex:  d9 db 73 4c 02 48 9b cc  8e 51 ad 3a             
        }
      }
      [1]=cryptoEPPwdHash {
        alias = dialedDigits "41100"
        timeStamp = 1279785517
        token = {
          algorithmOID = 1.2.840.113549.2.5
          paramS = {
          }
          hash = Hex:  21 d4 35 ef 75 9c 9f 50  ed f0 32 f3 65 26 a6 35 
        }
      }
    }
    keepAlive = false
    willSupplyUUIEs = true
    maintainConnection = false
    supportsAltGK = <<null>>
    usageReportingCapability = {
      nonStandardUsageTypes = 0 entries {
      }
      startTime = <<null>>
      endTime = <<null>>
      terminationCause = <<null>>
    }
    callCreditCapability = {
      canDisplayAmountString = true
      canEnforceDurationLimit = true
    }
    featureSet = {
      replacementFeatureSet = false
      supportedFeatures = 2 entries {
        [0]={
          id = standard 23
          parameters = 3 entries {
            [0]={
              id = standard 1
              content = bool true
            }
            [1]={
              id = standard 2
              content = bool true
            }
            [2]={
              id = standard 7
              content = bool true
            }
          }
        }
        [1]={
          id = oid 1.3.6.1.4.1.17090.0.6
          parameters = 2 entries {
            [0]={
              id = oid 1.3.6.1.4.1.17090.0.6.1
              content = number8 0
            }
            [1]={
              id = oid 1.3.6.1.4.1.17090.0.6.2
              content = bool false
            }
          }
        }
      }
    }
  }
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
registrationConfirm {
    requestSeqNum = 40602
    protocolIdentifier = 0.0.8.2250.0.6
    nonStandardData = {
      nonStandardIdentifier = h221NonStandard {
        t35CountryCode = 138
        t35Extension = 2
        manufacturerCode = 2
      }
      data =  5 octets {
        4e 6f 4e 41 54                                     NoNAT
      }
    }
    callSignalAddress = 1 entries {
      [0]=ipAddress {
        ip =  4 octets {
          a0 01 a0 a2                                        ..n,
        }
        port = 1721
      }
    }
    terminalAlias = 1 entries {
      [0]=dialedDigits "41100"
    }
    gatekeeperIdentifier =  6 characters {
      0047 004e 0055 0067 006b 0032             GNUgk2
    }
    endpointIdentifier =  9 characters {
      0038 0037 0038 0030 005f 0065 006e 0064   8780_end
      0070                                      p
    }
    timeToLive = 60
    willRespondToIRR = false
    maintainConnection = false
    serviceControl = 1 entries {
      [0]={
        sessionId = 0
        contents = callCreditServiceControl {
          callStartingPoint = connect <<null>>
        }
        reason = open <<null>>
      }
    }
    featureSet = {
      replacementFeatureSet = false
      supportedFeatures = 1 entries {
        [0]={
          id = oid 1.3.6.1.4.1.17090.0.6
        }
      }
    }
  }
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by Sprint
What will you do first with EVO, the first 4G phone?
Visit sprint.com/first -- http://p.sf.net/sfu/sprint-com-first
_______________________________________________________

Posting: mailto:Openh323gk-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Archive: http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/forum.php?forum_name=openh323gk-users
Unsubscribe: http://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/openh323gk-users
Homepage: http://www.gnugk.org/

[Index of Archives]     [SIP]     [Open H.323]     [Gnu Gatekeeper]     [Asterisk PBX]     [ISDN Cause Codes]     [Yosemite News]

  Powered by Linux