On Thu, Dec 27, 2012 at 05:14:54PM +0100, Antoine Pelisse wrote: > > Nicely analysed. Perhaps we would want new test pieces to define > > the behaviour we want to see first? > > I think we should. > > I also thought about the use case of "committed" and ignored directory > which is also broken to me (point 3 in the table below). By "committed", I assume you meat that you have "dirA/unco" as an untracked file, and "dirA/committed" as a file in the index? > Anyway I tried to make a table to sum-up/discuss the list of behaviors > we would like to see/test, taking Jeff mail into account. > (warning: that requires fixed width font) > > |----------------------+---------------------+---------------------------| > | Output | A. status --ignored | B. status --ignored -uall | > | | | (or with potential | > | | | --ignored=all) | > |----------------------+---------------------+---------------------------| > | 1. Untracked dirU | Current: | Current: | > | with ignored unco.ig | Empty | Empty | > | in it | | | > | | Expected: | Expected: | > | | !!dirU/ | !!dirU/unco.ig | > |----------------------+---------------------+---------------------------| > | 2. Untracked and | Current (OK): | Current: | > | ignored dirU with | !!dirU/ | !!dirU/ | > | file in it | | | > | | | Expected: | > | | | !!dirU/unco | > |----------------------+---------------------+---------------------------| > | 3. "Committed" dirA | Current: | Current: | > | yet ignored | Empty | Empty | > | with uncommitted | | | > | file in it | Expected: | Expected: | > | | dirA/ | dirA/unco | > |----------------------+---------------------+---------------------------| Thanks for putting this together. I agree with the expected output in each case, and I think this covers the cases we have seen (case 1 is Michael's original report, case 2 is what I wrote in my mail, and case 3 is the one you just came up with). I can't think offhand of any others. -Peff -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html