On Wed, 1 Oct 2003 17:32:39 +0200, "Guillermo S. Romero / Familia Romero" <famrom@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > Fine, I know about the order and the verbs, so I can not understand > why there seems to be a blind reasoning about shortcuts: not every app > requires the same functions nor the same usage pattern, so settings > lots of shortcuts that only seem to match text editors and browser > seems unreasonable. It does not "only seem to match text editors and browsers". The first examples of shortcuts that were posted at the beginning of this discussion (previous thread) mentioned the shortcuts used in Photoshop and Paint Shop Pro on Mac and Windows. > Gimp has collisions with other keys, you just > changed one, but there are more, if you want to comply, your work is > half done... and I will change back in my own config to make things > nice for a Gimp user instead than for a HIG writer. HIG is not set in > stone, and even then, it can be wrong. Yes, but on the other hand we should not invent or keep old shortcuts that are not used by any other applications if it would be possible to use some well-known shortcuts without significant drawbacks. Using the same shortcuts as some other applications would be a great help for the new users. So from my point of view, the list of choices for the Redo shortcut contains only two alternatives: Ctrl-Shift-Z or Ctrl-Y. We should pick one of these, but not the old shortcut. -Raphaël
