I simply don't like this idea, there is enough bugzilla noise and enough bureaucracy (read: obstacles) for anyone wanting to contribute (yes, even just clicking +1/-1 karma is a valuable contribution ...) - is this opinion worth 0.02€? :-) btw, reading the subject line, at first I understood it in a way that a negative karma comment will be mirrored into bugzilla comment of the appropriate bug _if it exists_ that would be good, IMO note that *I* do updates based on - fixing actual bugs - "fixing" bugs reported by updates monitoring so at least one bug exists for each update this may vary for different packages & contributors ... K. Dne St 27. června 2012 15:54:18, Jóhann B. Guðmundsson napsal(a): > Just bringing this topic to the appropriate mailing list > > On the last kernel meeting [1] it was suggested negative karma > points should be linked to a reported bug which kinda makes > sense if you think about it. > > What that means is that you ( as in reporter ) will no longer > be able to provide negative karma without linking it to an > already existing bug report either created by your or someone > else if that came to be. > > Now this has been discussed and rejected before by Fesco here > [2]. > > From my point of view FESCO should not be sticking their nose > in this topic since I think it's up to ourselves ( the QA > community ) to decide whether we want to implement this or not > hence I posted this here to this list for further discussion. > > I myself give +1 to implement this since give negative feedback > without linking to an already existing bug report helps no > one. > > There was also mentioned on the meeting that reporters seem to > be giving negative karma for bugs that never where mentioned > getting fixed in the updates. > > Doing this is a big NO NO since this will lead to fixes for > bugs that got mentioned being fixed in the update not reaching > our end user base because of that negative karma so I'm gonna > ask reporters that did that to stop doing that. > > Thanks > JBG > > > > > 1. > http://lists.fedoraproject.org/pipermail/kernel/2012-June/0038 > 86.html 2. > http://meetbot.fedoraproject.org/teams/fesco/fesco.2010-09-07-1 > 9.30.log.html -- Karel Volný QE BaseOs/Daemons Team Red Hat Czech, Brno tel. +420 532294274 (RH: +420 532294111 ext. 8262074) xmpp kavol@xxxxxxxxx :: "Never attribute to malice what can :: easily be explained by stupidity."
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
-- test mailing list test@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe: https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/test
