On Fri, Dec 04, 2020 at 10:23:08PM +0100, Petr Šabata wrote: > On Fri, Dec 4, 2020 at 8:48 PM Kevin Fenzi <kevin@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > > > On Thu, Dec 03, 2020 at 11:26:18PM +0100, Petr Šabata wrote: > > > Also a couple of notes on modularity here: > > > > > > # By default, module stream name is derived from the branch name > > > If we have any "master" modules, those will get unexpectedly renamed > > > as soon as they get rebuilt. This might impact tagging or updates and > > > cause confusion in general. We should check if there are any like that > > > and decide on further steps. > > > > Good thing to check yes. I can try and do so. > > Thanks. hum, but I am not 100% sure what I am looking for. modules with a master branch and no name defined? What does the name being defined look like in the yaml file? > > > > # Modules might be pulling components from their master branches to > > > build Rawhide artifacts > > > There are various use cases for this, too long to list. If the master > > > ref is no longer available, these will not build. Modulemd files that > > > pull components from master need to be updated after Phase 2. > > > > Yep. +1 > > Great, will you do that, too? There seems to be a bunch of them. ;( atomic/atomic.yaml: bootstrap: master atomic/atomic.yaml: ref: master atomic/atomic.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master eclipse/eclipse.yaml: ref: master fonts/fonts.yaml: bootstrap: master fonts/fonts.yaml: platform: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: bootstrap: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: 389-ds: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: bind: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: sssd: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: python2: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: # python2-ecosystem: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: python3: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: python3-ecosystem: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: platform: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: java: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: perl: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: 389-ds: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: bind: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: sssd: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: samba: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: pki: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: tomcat: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: resteasy: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: httpd: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: python2: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: python2-ecosystem: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: python3: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: python3-ecosystem: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: libtom: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: fonts: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master freeipa/freeipa.yaml: ref: master hardware-support/hardware-support.yaml: bootstrap: master hardware-support/hardware-support.yaml: platform: master hardware-support/hardware-support.yaml: host: master hardware-support/hardware-support.yaml: perl: master help2man/help2man.yaml: perl: master help2man/help2man.yaml: platform: master help2man/help2man.yaml: perl: master help2man/help2man.yaml: platform: master help2man/help2man.yaml: ref: master host/host.yaml: bootstrap: master host/host.yaml: platform: master installer-bootstrap/installer-bootstrap.yaml: bootstrap: master installer-bootstrap/installer-bootstrap.yaml: base-runtime: master installer-bootstrap/installer-bootstrap.yaml: bootstrap: master installer/installer.yaml: python3: master installer/installer.yaml: python3-ecosystem: master installer/installer.yaml: perl: master installer/installer.yaml: ref: master java/java.yaml: bootstrap: master java/java.yaml: platform: master java/java.yaml: fonts: master java/java.yaml: X11-base: master javapackages-tools/javapackages-tools.yaml: glassfish-master-pom: javapackages-tools/javapackages-tools.yaml: glassfish-master-pom, glassfish-servlet-api, javapackages-tools/javapackages-tools.yaml: glassfish-master-pom, glassfish-servlet-api, javapackages-tools/javapackages-tools.yaml: geronimo-parent-poms, glassfish-master-pom, jdk-11/jdk-11.yaml: jdk-10: [master] krb5/krb5.yaml: bootstrap: master krb5/krb5.yaml: platform: master libtom/libtom.yaml: bootstrap: master libtom/libtom.yaml: #platform: master libtom/libtom.yaml: #autotools: master libtom/libtom.yaml: #texlive: master libtom/libtom.yaml: platform: master mariadb/mariadb.yaml: bootstrap: master mariadb/mariadb.yaml: platform: master mariadb/mariadb.yaml: host: master mariadb/mariadb.yaml: networking-base: master memcached/memcached.yaml: ref: master mongodb/mongodb.yaml: bootstrap: master mongodb/mongodb.yaml: boost: master mongodb/mongodb.yaml: platform: master mongodb/mongodb.yaml: perl: master mongodb/mongodb.yaml: boost: master mysql/mysql.yaml: bootstrap: master mysql/mysql.yaml: platform: master mysql/mysql.yaml: host: master mysql/mysql.yaml: hardware-support: master networking-base/networking-base.yaml: bootstrap: master networking-base/networking-base.yaml: platform: master networking-base/networking-base.yaml: perl: master networking-base/networking-base.yaml: python3: master networking-base/networking-base.yaml: python3-ecosystem: master nginx/nginx.yaml: base-runtime: master nginx/nginx.yaml: base-runtime: master ntp/ntp.yaml: base-runtime: master ntp/ntp.yaml: base-runtime: master perl-libintl-perl/perl-libintl-perl.yaml: perl: master perl-libintl-perl/perl-libintl-perl.yaml: platform: master perl-libintl-perl/perl-libintl-perl.yaml: host: master perl-libintl-perl/perl-libintl-perl.yaml: perl: master perl-libintl-perl/perl-libintl-perl.yaml: ref: master perl-libintl-perl/perl-libintl-perl.yaml: ref: master perl-libintl-perl/perl-libintl-perl.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: platform: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: perl: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: host: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: perl: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install-bootstrap/perl-Module-Install-bootstrap.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: platform: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: perl: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: perl-Module-Install-bootstrap: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: host: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: perl: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Install/perl-Module-Install.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: perl: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: perl-Module-Install: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: perl-Moo: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: platform: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: host: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: perl: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: perl-Module-Install: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: perl-Moo: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Module-Package/perl-Module-Package.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: platform: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: perl: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: host: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: perl: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Moo/perl-Moo.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: perl: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: perl-Module-Install: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: perl-Module-Package: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: platform: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: host: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: perl-Moo: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: perl: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth/perl-Unicode-EastAsianWidth.yaml: ref: master postgresql/postgresql.yaml: bootstrap: master postgresql/postgresql.yaml: platform: master proftpd/proftpd.yaml: base-runtime: master proftpd/proftpd.yaml: base-runtime: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: bootstrap: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: platform: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: java: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: apache-commons: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: maven: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master resteasy/resteasy.yaml: ref: master rsyslog/rsyslog.yaml: #perl: master rsyslog/rsyslog.yaml: #python2: master rsyslog/rsyslog.yaml: #python3: master rsyslog/rsyslog.yaml: #!!TEMPORARY!! - switch to master/upstream/etc. branch once varnish module gets updated !! rsyslog/rsyslog.yaml: documentation: http://www.rsyslog.com/doc/master/index.html ruby/ruby.yaml: ref: master ruby/ruby.yaml: ref: master ruby/ruby.yaml: ref: master ruby/ruby.yaml: ref: master ruby/ruby.yaml: ref: master ruby/ruby.yaml: ref: master samba/samba.yaml: bootstrap: master samba/samba.yaml: platform: master samba/samba.yaml: python2: master samba/samba.yaml: python2-ecosystem: master samba/samba.yaml: libtom: master shim/shim.yaml: bootstrap: master sssd/sssd.yaml: bootstrap: master sssd/sssd.yaml: platform: master sssd/sssd.yaml: samba: master sssd/sssd.yaml: python3: master sssd/sssd.yaml: python3-ecosystem: master swig/swig.yaml: platform: master swig/swig.yaml: autotools: master swig/swig.yaml: boost: master swig/swig.yaml: help2man: master swig/swig.yaml: perl: master swig/swig.yaml: python2: master swig/swig.yaml: python3: master swig/swig.yaml: platform: master swig/swig.yaml: perl: master swig/swig.yaml: ref: master swig/swig.yaml: ref: master swig/swig.yaml: ref: master system-tools/system-tools.yaml: bootstrap: master system-tools/system-tools.yaml: platform: master system-tools/system-tools.yaml: ref: master system-tools/system-tools.yaml: ref: master system-tools/system-tools.yaml: ref: master system-tools/system-tools.yaml: ref: master system-tools/system-tools.yaml: ref: master testmodule2/testmodule2.yaml: testmodule: [master, 2.0] testmodule2/testmodule2.yaml: testmodule: [master, 2.0] testmodule2/testmodule2.yaml: ref: master testmodule/testmodule.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: bootstrap: master texlive/texlive.yaml: platform: master texlive/texlive.yaml: perl: master texlive/texlive.yaml: X11-base: master texlive/texlive.yaml: fonts: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: # ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: # ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master texlive/texlive.yaml: ref: master tomcat/tomcat.yaml: ref: master tomcat/tomcat.yaml: ref: master udisks2/udisks2.yaml: bootstrap: master udisks2/udisks2.yaml: platform: master udisks2/udisks2.yaml: python3: master varnish/varnish.yaml: bootstrap: master varnish/varnish.yaml: base-runtime: master X11-base/X11-base.yaml: bootstrap: master X11-base/X11-base.yaml: platform: master X11-base/X11-base.yaml: fonts: master X11-base/X11-base.yaml: autotools: master > > > # The modulemd component ref is optional and defaults to master > > > Unless this got changed later, if the ref field is omitted, the value > > > defaults to "master". This is part of the specification and is handled > > > by libmodulemd. Not sure how to proceed here. > > > > Can we change the default? > > According to Vít that's already happened (for completely unrelated > reasons), so we're good here. ok. > > > And besides modularity: > > > > > > There are people and teams who use bots to autobuild their upstream > > > projects in Rawhide. If they have a bot account (and I hope they do), > > > they should be notified to update their tooling. > > > > We don't have much tracking on bot accounts. People make them and sign > > up for fas for them, etc. > > > > We can try and find things that are obvious, but we are likely to miss > > some. We can definitely help people who notice breakage tho. > > Ah, I kinda expected these accounts to be clearly marked as being > non-human. Oh well. > > Anyway, besides the magical module stream renames, all of this should > continue to work fine if we get the symbolic refs, I think? Well, I am ok with a symbolic ref from main to/from rawhide, but I don't like the idea of a master symbolic ref. It kind of defeats the purpose of the entire thing. ;( kevin
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: PGP signature
_______________________________________________ devel mailing list -- devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe send an email to devel-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Fedora Code of Conduct: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/project/code-of-conduct/ List Guidelines: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines List Archives: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
