a. ntpd/ntpdate aren't installed by default with Fedora 19. I don't see the feature proposing this be changed. b. A default installation of Fedora 18/19, has no means of updating the RTC correctly if it's off by more than 15 minutes; and 60 minutes with newer kernels. An RTC wrong by more than an hour, e.g. two months ago, if I have an internet connection chrony sets the system clock to the correct date/time. If I don't have an internet connection, I'm relegated to a system time based on the wrong RTC, which seems grossly broken to me. c. Windows and OS X do not behave this way - almost immediately upon getting correct time from an internet source, those OS's update the RTC to the correct time. d. This long bug, 816752, suggests, as a solution, installing ntpdate in order to set the RTC. So if ntpdate is being deprecated as part of the proposed feature, why is installing and using ntpdate being suggested as a fix for the lack of chrony-kernel RTC sync support? https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=816752#c75 e. Why isn't this functionality being added to chrony, rather than bouncing us back to ntpd? The time situation on Fedora makes me think the left hand and right hand are doing different things. Chris Murphy -- devel mailing list devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/devel
