On 09/26/2022, Serge Semin wrote: > On Mon, Sep 26, 2022 at 04:31:28PM +0200, Christoph Hellwig wrote: > > On Mon, Sep 26, 2022 at 03:49:24PM +0300, Serge Semin wrote: > > > @Christoph, @Marek, @Bjorn, @Rob could you please join to the > > > DMA-mask related discussion. @Lorenzo can't decide which driver should > > > initialize the device DMA-mask. > > > > > The driver that does the actual DMA mapping or allocation functions > > need to set it. But even with your comments on the questions I'm > > still confused what struct device you are even talking about. Can > > you explain this a bit better? > > We are talking about the DW PCIe Root Port controller with DW eDMA engine > embedded. It' simplified structure can be represented as follows: > > +---------------+ +--------+ > | System memory | | CPU(s) | > +---------------+ +--------+ > ^ | | ^ > | ... System bus ... | > ... | | ... > | v v | > +------------+------+--------+----------+------+ > | DW PCIe RP | AXI-m| | AXI-s/DBI| | > | +------+ +----------+ | > | ^ ^ | | > | +------+----+ | CSRs | > | v v v | > | +-------+ +---------+ +----------+ | > | | eDMA | | in-iATU | | out-iATU | | > | +-------+ +---------+ +----------+ | > | ^ ^ ^ | > | +--------+--+---+-------+ | > +------------------| PIPE |--------------------+ > +------+ > | ^ > v | > PCIe bus > > The DW PCIe controller device is instantiated as a platform device > defined in the system DT source file. The device is probed by the > DW PCIe low-level driver, which after the platform-specific setups > initiates the generic DW PCIe host-controller registration. On the way > of that procedure the DW PCIe core tries to auto-detect the DW eDMA > engine availability. If the engine is found, the DW eDMA probe method > is called in order to register the DMA-engine device. After that the > PCIe host bridge is registered. Both the PCIe host-bridge and > DMA-engine devices will have the DW PCIe platform device as parent. > > Getting back to the sketch above. Here is a short description of the > content: > 1. DW eDMA is capable of performing the data transfers from/to System > memory to/from PCIe bus memory. > 2. in-iATU is the Inbound Address Translation Unit, which is > responsible for the PCIe bus peripheral devices to access the system > memory. The "dma-ranges" DT-property is used to initialize the > PCIe<->Sys memory mapping. (@William note the In-iATU setup doesn't > affect the eDMA transfers.) > 3. out-iATU is responsible for the CPU(s) to access the PCIe bus > peripheral devices memory/cfg-space. > > So eDMA and in-iATU are using the same AXI-master interface to access > the system memory. Thus the DMAable memory capability is the same for > both of them (Though in-iATU may have some specific mapping based on > the "dma-ranges" DT-property setup). Neither DW eDMA nor DW PCIe Root > Port CSRs region have any register to auto-detect the AXI-m interface > address bus width. It's selected during the IP-core synthesize and is > platform-specific. The question is: "What driver/code is supposed to > set the DMA-mask of the DW PCIe platform device?" Seeing the parental > platform device is used to perform the memory-mapping for both DW eDMA > clients and PCIe-bus peripheral device drivers, and seeing the AXI-m > interface parameters aren't auto-detectable and are platform-specific, > the only place it should be done in is the DW PCIe low-level device > driver. I don't really see any alternative... What is your opinion? > > -Sergey I believe this eDMA implementation is new for an upstream DW PCIe device driver, right? If so, this will require some refactoring of the DMA mask code, but you need to also make sure you don't break the MSI target address use case that prompted this 32-bit DMA mask change -- [1]. My changes were directly related to allowing the DW PCIe device driver to fallback to a 64-bit DMA mask for the MSI target address if there are no 32-bit allocations available. For that use-case, using a 32-bit mask doesn't have any perf impact here since there is no actual DMAs happening. Would it be possible for the DW PCIe device driver to set a capabilities flag that the PCIe host controller can read and set the mask accordingly. This way you don't need to go fix up any drivers that require a 32-bit DMA'able address for the MSI target address. For example, I see several of the PCI capability features have 64-bit flags, e.g. PCI_MSI_FLAGS_64BIT and PCI_X_STATUS_64BIT. If not, then you're going to have to re-work the host controller driver and DW PCIe device drivers that require a 32-bit MSI target address. [1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/20201117165312.25847-1-vidyas@xxxxxxxxxx/ Thanks, Will
