NYTimes.com Article: Discounter From Out West Is Gnawing at Air Canada

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



This article from NYTimes.com
has been sent to you by psa188@xxxxxxxxx



/-------------------- advertisement -----------------------\

THE DREAMERS - IN SELECT CITIES FEBRUARY 6

Set against the turbulent political backdrop of 1968 France
when the voice of youth was reverberating around Europe,
THE DREAMERS is a story of self-discovery as three students
test each other to see just how far they will go. "Pure
Bertolucci," proclaims The New Yorker. THE DREAMERS makes
its North American premiere at the 2004 Sundance Film
Festival.

http://www.foxsearchlight.com/thedreamers/index_nyt.html

\----------------------------------------------------------/

Discounter From Out West Is Gnawing at Air Canada

January 30, 2004
 By BERNARD SIMON





TORONTO, Jan. 29 - As a captain with WestJet Airlines,
Allen Byl estimates that his salary is about one-third less
than that of his counterparts at Air Canada. The only place
outside Canada he occasionally spends a night is Cancún,
and chances are slim that he will ever command a plane
bigger than a Boeing 737. Yet Mr. Byl has no desire to fly
for a different airline.

"I don't think anyone comes here for the money," Mr. Byl
said in a telephone interview from his home in Calgary,
Alberta, where WestJet is based. "It's the way we do things
and the way we work together."

The way WestJet does things is sending fissures through the
Canadian air travel model.

Started by four Calgary entrepreneurs in 1996, WestJet is
by no means the first airline to take on Air Canada, by far
this nation's biggest. But Air Canada, based in Montreal,
has either swallowed or crushed all previous comers.

Much has changed in recent years. Like full-service
airlines in many other countries, Air Canada has had to
re-examine the premises of its business model. Burdened by
high costs and heavy debt, it sought court protection from
its creditors last April, and is now in the throes of a
restructuring. Its fleet has shrunk by a quarter, and it
has laid off thousands of workers.

Air Canada registered a loss of 1.1 billion Canadian
dollars ($830.1 million) in the first nine months of 2003.

A new flock of low-cost carriers, with WestJet at the
fore, are now gnawing at Air Canada's business. According
to the transportation department in Ottawa, Air Canada's
share of domestic seat capacity shrank to less than 60
percent at the end of 2003 from as much as 87 percent at
the beginning of 2000. During the same period, WestJet's
share grew from 5.5 percent to 24.6 percent.

The other fledgling carriers, like Jetsgo of Montreal and
CanJet Airlines, based in Nova Scotia, together have
doubled their share of capacity to 15.5 percent.

"Twenty years ago, the sentiment was that if you didn't
take Air Canada, you might be taking a bit of a chance on
the safety front," said Warren Everson, vice president for
policy and strategic planning at the Air Transport
Association of Canada. "That doesn't exist any more."

Mr. Everson said that Canadians still show "enormous
loyalty" to Air Canada when they travel abroad. But on
domestic routes, he said, "There's been an increasing
carelessness about which carrier you fly."

WestJet is closely modeled on Southwest Airlines of Dallas,
with a sharp eye on costs and an informal corporate
culture. It flies only Boeing 737's, does not transfer
passengers' baggage to other flights and has no business
class.

The airline has posted a profit for 28 consecutive
quarters, with net income of 60.5 million Canadian dollars
($46.7 million) in 2003. WestJet's unit costs were 10.4
Canadian cents a seat mile in the fourth quarter, compared
with about 18.5 cents at Air Canada.

"Our costs will remain almost half of theirs and continue
to decline," Clive J. Beddoe, WestJet's chief executive,
told analysts last week.

Like Southwest, WestJet has developed its own personal,
informal mood. "Compared to Air Canada, the culture is
vastly different," said Gerard Seijts, an assistant
professor at the Richard Ivey School of Business, part of
the University of Western Ontario. According to Mr. Seijts,
who uses WestJet as a case study in his classes on
organizational behavior, WestJet's culture is "spunky and
enthusiastic." With no unions, he said, "There's a lot of
peer pressure to do what's right for the company."

WestJet's pilots and flight attendants regularly entertain
passengers - called guests - with songs and jokes. One
recent onboard announcement went like this: "In the
unlikely event of a loss of cabin pressure, the panels
above your head will open, and the cabin attendants' phone
numbers will fall out."

In a recent survey by KPMG and Ipsos-Reid, 255 chief
executives chose WestJet as Canada's second "most
respected" corporation, up from the No. 7 spot in 2002. The
Royal Bank of Canada, the country's biggest financial
institution, took first place.

Mr. Beddoe, 56, who is also one of WestJet's four founders,
said in an interview that his airline faced a bigger
challenge than Southwest in containing costs because of
Canada's relatively sparse and widely scattered population.
For instance, on its busiest route, between Calgary and
Vancouver, WestJet offers 11 round-trip flights a day -
including two that make other stops. In contrast, Southwest
offers 29 round-trip flights on weekdays between Dallas and
Houston.

WestJet has sought to overcome that cost disadvantage by
paying lower salaries, but offering relatively generous
profit-sharing and stock purchase arrangements.

Employees can spend up to 20 percent of their salaries on
WestJet shares, with the company matching their purchases.
"It's pretty hard to lose on that deal," said Mr. Byl, the
pilot. The airline's stock has risen more than sixfold
since it went public in 1999. It gained 2.4 percent
Thursday, to 28.35 Canadian dollars on the Toronto
exchange.

Currently, 87 percent of WestJet's 3,700 employees own
shares; they spend an average of 13 percent of their
salaries on stock purchases.

As WestJet grows, it is making some compromises on its
original strategy. It announced this month that it would
move its main hub in the busy southern Ontario market from
a small airport in the steel-making city of Hamilton, about
an hour outside Toronto, to Toronto's international
airport. The airline hopes that higher traffic will offset
a significant increase in landing fees and other operating
costs.

It is also installing satellite TV on its planes, and
giving passengers a couple of more inches of leg room.

With WestJet's route network expanding in central and
eastern Canada, its flights have become longer, raising
costs over which it has little control, like fuel.

Scheduled service to the United States is in the pipeline.
"All the regulatory approvals are in place," Mr. Beddoe
said, declining to say where WestJet would fly. The timing,
he said, will depend on the extent to which domestic
business is opened up by Air Canada's shifting its focus to
international routes.

John Reber, an Air Canada spokesman, said that "it doesn't
make business sense to pursue market share growth" in
Canada, meeting the no-frills competition head on. He
added, however, that the airline "is not reducing in any
fashion our business in the domestic market."

Mr. Seijts noted that WestJet's offbeat culture could
become a victim of the airline's growth.

"If the company is getting another 5,000 employees across
the country, will the people still be as enthusiastic?" Mr.
Seijts said. The move from Hamilton to Toronto, he said,
"is away from the original business model that makes them
great." And WestJet, like Air Canada, faces a tougher
market as other low-cost start-ups arise, he said.

Responding to such concerns, Mr. Beddoe said that the
carrier's continued success is "very much a function of who
you hire and how intolerant you are of people who don't fit
the culture."

All four of WestJet's founders still work for the airline.
About 1,000 job applications come in each week, and filling
each job takes an average of 18 hours of interviews, Mr.
Beddoe said. "We're very selective about whom we hire."

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/30/business/worldbusiness/30westjet.html?ex=1076473470&ei=1&en=ab7cbabc3342a736


---------------------------------

Get Home Delivery of The New York Times Newspaper. Imagine
reading The New York Times any time & anywhere you like!
Leisurely catch up on events & expand your horizons. Enjoy
now for 50% off Home Delivery! Click here:

http://www.nytimes.com/ads/nytcirc/index.html



HOW TO ADVERTISE
---------------------------------
For information on advertising in e-mail newsletters
or other creative advertising opportunities with The
New York Times on the Web, please contact
onlinesales@xxxxxxxxxxx or visit our online media
kit at http://www.nytimes.com/adinfo

For general information about NYTimes.com, write to
help@xxxxxxxxxxxx

Copyright 2003 The New York Times Company

[Index of Archives]         [NTSB]     [NASA KSC]     [Yosemite]     [Steve's Art]     [Deep Creek Hot Springs]     [NTSB]     [STB]     [Share Photos]     [Yosemite Campsites]