On 07/10/17 11:10, Tim wrote: > Allegedly, on or about 09 July 2017, Stephen Morris sent: >> Sorry, I wasn't referring to TB's reply functionality as being a list issue, I >> agree with you that the functionality implemented by TB is stupid, and I'll see if >> I can post an issue on it on the post site that was discussing all the plugin >> support issues in Firefox and possibly TB that were originating with versions 52/53. > I'm wondering if that irritating behaviour can be bug reported as being non-RFC > compliant. Thunderbird's behaviour is a serious screw-up. Well, your assertion has been cause for continual debate over the years. If one were to consider only RFC-822 they probably have a fairly strong argument. But, as I think you know, there has been quite a bit of exchanges concerning munging of headers by mailing list SW. Now, there is RFC 2822 which obsoletes RFC 822. It "clarifies" things a bit in section 3.6.2 “Originator fields”. The relevant portion states: When the "Reply-To:" field is present, it indicates the mailbox(es) to which the author of the message suggeststhat replies be sent. The contention is that the mailing list software is not the "author" and therefore should not be adding this to the headers and if it appears in a message from a mailing list it should be ignored. There is RFC 2369 which is related to mailing lists and it provides a List-Post header which it is suggested should be the header mail clients honor. I have not checked the code or done any experiments, but I've seen it claimed that kmail is now using the List-Post header to determine what the default "Reply" means. The claim is the have a "Reply to Author" option to override. The difficulty (at least for me) is that if you right click on any message in kmail and look at the reply options you get all the options including "reply to list" even if the message isn't from a mailing list. So, to check the claim one would have to look at the code or manually edit the mail in the message store and check how that affects behavior of the default reply action. So, I think it could be argued that if T-Bird is going to ignore the Reply-To header for messages from a mailing list they should have at the same time added support for the default reply of mailing list messages use the List-Post header. -- Fedora Users List - The place to go to speculate endlessly
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ users mailing list -- users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe send an email to users-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
