On 2011/10/17 06:50, Marko Vojinovic wrote:
> On Monday 17 October 2011 02:34:47 Tom Horsley wrote:
>> On Sun, 16 Oct 2011 20:20:35 -0500
>>
>> Chris Adams wrote:
>>> Define "first". Hint: that's not a solvable problem on general PC
>>> hardware (thus, biosdevname). There have been many problems over the
>>> years where the ordering changed on some hardware from one kernel
>>> release to the next.
>>
>> Well, either biosdevname is also a nonsolvable problem, or a
>> perfectly wonderful definition of "first" is simply "The
>> lexicographic ordering of the biosdevname generated name strings".
>
> Suppose you have a server with a two-port ethernet PCI card plugged into the
> second PCI slot on the motherboard. The biosdevname names are p2p1 and p2p2.
> By your definition, they would map to eth0 and eth1, right?
>
> Now, at some point you decide to upgrade your hardware by adding an aditional
> two-port ethernet card in PCI slot 1. The biosdevname names for the new ports
> are p1p1 and p1p2, while p2p1 and p2p2 stay the same, as before. But this
> time, according to your proposal, eth0 and eth1 would not correspond to p2p1
> and p2p2, but to the new ports, p1p1 and p1p2, while the p2p1 and p2p2 would
> be renamed eth2 and eth3. Assuming that you plug all the cables back to their
> original positions, every script that refers to eth0 and eth1 is now broken,
> while every script that refers to p2p1 and p2p2 still works.
>
> IIUC, this is one of the problems that biosdevname is meant to fix. The concept
> of physical location is a well-defined one, while the concept of linearly
> ordered (lexicographically or otherwise) location is ill-defined. Hence the
> names are given according to the physial location rather than to any
> particular ordering.
There is something wrong with ethp2p3? What KIND of device is easier to fathom
if it is part of the name, ya know.
{o.o}
--
users mailing list
users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe or change subscription options:
https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/users
Guidelines: http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines
