#9: board vote on reorganization proposals ---------------------+--------------------- Reporter: mattdm | Owner: Status: new | Priority: normal Component: General | Resolution: Keywords: | ---------------------+--------------------- Comment (by gholms): A: -1 B: -1 C: +1 Comments/recommendations: * Proposal A rests the project's high-level decisions solely upon the FPL's shoulders. This introduces a project-wide point of failure (in the short term) that is particularly unfair to the FPL, who quite likely has his or her own goals within Fedora and a life outside of Fedora. Whether based in reality or not, it also creates the appearance of a "good old boys" network. * Proposal B merely creates a new group to lead in place of the Board. It does nothing to encourage the other group, who still make decisions, to be active themselves. * Proposal C needs to explicitly mention that someone can say "-1" when he or she believes an unannounced change needs review. Rollbacks are often not straightforward when one is not working with code. * Proposals A and C need more elaboration about who the groups' members will be to ensure reasonable representation and prevent needless obstacles to progress. -- Ticket URL: <https://fedorahosted.org/board/ticket/9#comment:6> board <https://fedorahosted.org/board> Fedora Project Board Public Tickets _______________________________________________ board-discuss mailing list board-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/board-discuss
