[xfs@xxxxxxxxxxx is where you'll find the XFS developers] On Mon, Jul 04, 2016 at 05:32:40AM +0000, Wang Shilong wrote: > Hello Guys, > > I happened run some benchmarks for XFS, and found some intresting to share here: > Kernel version: > [root@localhost shm]# uname -r > 4.7.0-rc5+ > > [root@localhost shm]# cat /proc/cpuinfo | grep Intel > vendor_id : GenuineIntel > model name : Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-4770 CPU @ 3.40GHz > > dd 16GB to /dev/shm/data to use memory backend storage to benchmark metadata performaces. > > Benchmark tool is mdtest, you can download it from > https://sourceforge.net/projects/mdtest/ > > Steps to run benchmark > #mkfs.xfs /dev/shm/data > #mount /dev/shm/data /mnt/test > #mdtest -d /mnt/test -n 2000000 > > 1 tasks, 2000000 files/directories > > SUMMARY: (of 1 iterations) > Operation Max Min Mean Std Dev > --------- --- --- ---- ------- > Directory creation: 24724.717 24724.717 24724.717 0.000 > Directory stat : 1156009.290 1156009.290 1156009.290 0.000 > Directory removal : 103496.353 103496.353 103496.353 0.000 > File creation : 23094.444 23094.444 23094.444 0.000 > File stat : 1158704.969 1158704.969 1158704.969 0.000 > File read : 752731.595 752731.595 752731.595 0.000 > File removal : 105481.766 105481.766 105481.766 0.000 > Tree creation : 2229.827 2229.827 2229.827 0.000 > Tree removal : 1.275 1.275 1.275 0.000 > > -- finished at 07/04/2016 12:54:26 -- > > IOPS for file creation is only 2.3W, however compare to Ext4 with same testing. > Operation Max Min Mean Std Dev > --------- --- --- ---- ------- > Directory creation: 65875.462 65875.462 65875.462 0.000 > Directory stat : 1060115.356 1060115.356 1060115.356 0.000 > Directory removal : 109955.606 109955.606 109955.606 0.000 > File creation : 114898.425 114898.425 114898.425 0.000 > File stat : 1046223.044 1046223.044 1046223.044 0.000 > File read : 699663.339 699663.339 699663.339 0.000 > File removal : 152320.304 152320.304 152320.304 0.000 > Tree creation : 19065.018 19065.018 19065.018 0.000 > Tree removal : 1.269 1.269 1.269 0.000 > > IOPS of file creation is more than 11W!!! > > I understand Ext4 use Hash index tree and XFS use B+ tree for directroy, so i test Btrfs > for this case. > --------- --- --- ---- ------- > Directory creation: 99312.866 99312.866 99312.866 0.000 > Directory stat : 1116205.199 1116205.199 1116205.199 0.000 > Directory removal : 66441.011 66441.011 66441.011 0.000 > File creation : 91282.930 91282.930 91282.930 0.000 > File stat : 1117636.580 1117636.580 1117636.580 0.000 > File read : 754964.332 754964.332 754964.332 0.000 > File removal : 69708.657 69708.657 69708.657 0.000 > Tree creation : 29746.837 29746.837 29746.837 0.000 > Tree removal : 1.289 1.289 1.289 0.000 > > Even Btrfs, it got about 9W.... > > Hmm..Maybe this is because too many files under single directory?(200W won't be too much i guess) > I reduce number of files for XFS to 50W. > 1 tasks, 500000 files/directories > > SUMMARY: (of 1 iterations) > Operation Max Min Mean Std Dev > --------- --- --- ---- ------- > Directory creation: 53021.632 53021.632 53021.632 0.000 > Directory stat : 1187581.191 1187581.191 1187581.191 0.000 > Directory removal : 108112.695 108112.695 108112.695 0.000 > File creation : 51654.911 51654.911 51654.911 0.000 > File stat : 1180447.310 1180447.310 1180447.310 0.000 > File read : 755391.001 755391.001 755391.001 0.000 > File removal : 108415.353 108415.353 108415.353 0.000 > Tree creation : 2129.088 2129.088 2129.088 0.000 > Tree removal : 5.272 5.272 5.272 0.000 > > -- finished at 07/04/2016 12:59:17 -- > > So performances go up from 2.3W to 5.1W, but still very slow compared to others... > > > PS: mkfs options for Btrfs is: mkfs.btrfs -m single -d single -f > mkfs options for XFS is: mkfs.xfs -f > mkfs options for Ext4 is: mkfs.ext4 -i 2048(to generate enough inodes for testing) > > Best Regards, > Shilong > -- > To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-xfs" in > the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx > More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html > -- Dave Chinner david@xxxxxxxxxxxxx _______________________________________________ xfs mailing list xfs@xxxxxxxxxxx http://oss.sgi.com/mailman/listinfo/xfs
