On Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 10:43 AM, L. Rahyen <research@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > On Friday March 21 2008 17:02:33 Mark Knecht wrote: > > As an alternative, decouple the forum and the list and get helpful folks to > > pay attention to the forums. > > Main point of creating ML <-> forum link was to not fragment user base and > allow people who don't like forums (and want to use ML) but can (and want) > to help to the users. Personally I don't like forums very much (however I can > use them if necessary but without ML <-> forum link it would simply be > impractical for me to read so much messages per day) but I understand why > some other people like them. > > > > Personally I'd prefer the list not be split. > > +1. And I want to say that I don't see any problem actually. This list exist > for helping users. For advanced users who's questions aren't suitable for > wine-users we already have separate list - wine-devel. So for people who want > to ask/answer advanced questions wine-devel is best place. > +1. Anyone claiming that wine-users hasn't been filled with newbie questions before the linkup hasn't been on the list for very long. In the wine community, you either know how to use Wine or you don't. Those that don't know ask for help on wine-users. Those that do know how to use Wine submit bug reports for non-working apps. Adding another list completely defeats the purpose of linking the ML and forum. We added the link to reduce fragmentation, and that has happened. We're reaching out to a user base that formerly had no connection with experienced wine users. For those considering adding a newbies list, keep in mind that the few have shouted above the many, and some of those shouters have said they aren't willing to help the newbies in any circumstance. We've provided an alternative solution for those that can't handle dealing with new users. They can, and some have, removed themselves from wine-users. They can also easily filter the wine-forum messages. With that being said, please reconsider adding yet another ML. -- James Hawkins
