[ Trimming Cc lines a little bit ]. On Tue, Aug 11, 2015 at 12:32:22PM +0200, Karel Zak wrote: > I think Posix standard is pretty explicit: > > EXIT STATUS > The following exit values shall be returned: > 0 Receiving messages is allowed. > 1 Receiving messages is not allowed. > >1 An error occurred. > > > but you're asking for 0 also when 'n' or 'y' operants are specified. > For me it seems like complicated return code semantic... It is not complicated, it is usual Unix behaviour: Most commands return 0 on success and > 0 on error (often, they return a different number > 0 according to the type of error). If I say "mesg n", and the mesg command is actually able to disable writes to the terminal, that should count as successful, because it did what I asked it. But it still exits with 1, which usually indicates error, and this forces shell script writers to write extra code. I would call *that* complicated, not the current behaviour. > I think standard wants to keep the things simple and stupid without > any extra exceptions (another exit codes when executed with operants). > [...] On the contrary, I think standard is simple but not because they tried to make it simple, but just because they forgot to make it *sensible*, apparently nobody thought that it is probably a lot more useful to leave the 0 and 1 error codes only for the case where an argument is not used. I can understand that you guys want to follow the standard (after all, if a program follows the standard, it is not a bug in the program by definition), but to me this seems like a bug in the standard itself, as explained. Unfortunately, I'm just speaking as an end user here. If nothing I say about this makes sense to you, ok, do nothing, but it would be wonderdul if you, as the authors, would ask the standard to be clarified or modified, as you are in a much better position to do so. Thanks. -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe util-linux" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
