On Wed, 13 Nov 2019 22:05:06 +0100 "ajh-valmer" <ajh.valmer@xxxxxxx> wrote: > On Wednesday 13 November 2019 21:13:32 Michael wrote: > > > > - Get a working system with nouveau. > > > Or not. Do not confuse the nouveau kernel driver with the nouveau DDX (X > > > and Wayland) driver. The nouveau kernel driver provides the kernel mode > > > setting functionality that competent DDXes depend on. > > > Xserver-xorg-video-nouveau is a reverse-engineered, *optional*, DDX built > > > only for NVidia GPUs. The default DDX is newer technology, automatically > > > used when: 1-it supports any non-ancient (AMD or Intel or NVidia) GPU; > > > 2-KMS is not disabled; and 3-no optional DDX is installed. It can also be > > > explicitly configured to be used even though an applicable optional DDX is > > > available. It's provided by the xserver-org package itself. When in use, > > > modeset(0) will normally be found copiously in Xorg.0.log. > > > The modesetting DDX is in use here by all the NVidia GPUs I have that are > > > new enough for it to support, those newer than approximately 10-12 years > > > of age. > > > Old mainframe guys like myself probably shouldn't be giving GPU advice ;) > > It worked perfectly with Stretch, nvidia non free and xserver-xorg, > and with Buster, completely broken. > > I tried, nvidia free and non-free, no result. > > I cannot spend hours and hours to repair... First, do you have the correct driver package? There are ~7 nVidia proprietary driver series, each of which supports different cards. If you're not sure, check http://us.download.nvidia.com/XFree86/Linux-x86_64/430.50/README/supportedchips.html Having the wrong driver, or parts of it not correcty installed, might create the symptoms you're seeing. Newer cards will sometimes work with older drivers, but it isn't guaranteed. Keep in mind that, in addition to matching the card you're using, the driver must support your kernel version *and* your X server version. That's why it's safest to install from your distro's repository if you're going to use the nVidia proprietary drivers—they should have those details worked out for you. Nouveau isn't a perfect solution either. It doesn't support the full range of nVidia cards, or the full range of features on every card it does handle, and it doesn't play nice with TDE if compiled into the kernel—you have to ensure it was built as a module. And you can't have it installed on the same system as the proprietary driver at the same time without blacklisting one kernel module or the other. Your ultimate fallback is the vesa driver. Make sure it's installed. It should be enough for you to be able to bring up a graphical desktop in a pinch. (Source: I have one desktop with a recent nVidia card running the proprietary driver, and one laptop with an ancient nVidia card that I transitioned to nouveau last year. Both run TDE. I have committed just about every possible nVidia-related idiocy at one time or another. However, I'm on a different distro from you, so my insight is a bit limited.) E. Liddell --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: trinity-users-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx For additional commands, e-mail: trinity-users-help@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Read list messages on the web archive: http://trinity-users.pearsoncomputing.net/ Please remember not to top-post: http://trinity.pearsoncomputing.net/mailing_lists/#top-posting
