Re: Services enabled in an nspawn container on an nfsroot

[Lennart Poettering <lennart@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On Sa, 23.05.20 15:07, Antoine Pietri (antoine.pietri1@xxxxxxxxx) wrote:

> Hi,
>
> I have a setup where my NFS server exports its /export/nfsroot for my
> diskless clients.
> To ease the deployment of this nfsroot, I'd like to be able to run
> ansible roles directly in there to install the packages and
> configurations directly in the nfsroot. I thought using an nspawn
> container would be a good way to achieve that.
>
> So I first symlinked my nfsroot like this: ln -s /export/nfsroot
> /var/lib/machines
> Then I created a very simple nfsroot.nspawn file (Exec.Boot=true,
> Network.Private=yes) and enabled this container. It works fine, if I
> enable SSH I can install whatever I want through ansible.
>
> Now my issue is this: there are some services that I'd like to enable
> for the diskless boot clients (lightdm will not start properly in my
> container), and some I'd like to only enable for the container (I
> don't need systemd-networkd in my clients because they will inherit
> their network configuration from the PXE stack).
>
> What is the best way to have a separate set of services that I enable
> when running as a container and when running from the diskless boot?
> The potential solutions I see are:
>
> - Masking the services individually on the kernel command line
> - Using two targets (container.target / nfsroot.target) which specify
> what they require and starting them from the kernel command line
> (after having disabled all the services)
> - Using systemd.preset(5) (maybe with a bind mount of a preset file in
> the container)
> - Creating an override file for each service with a line like
> ConditionVirtualization=container
>
> Maybe I'm missing an easier way? My preference would be to have a
> whitelist of services that I start when running in the container
> (which would probably only be sshd and systemd-networkd to allow
> ansible deployments), and ignore everything else.


I would probably pull in all services all the time, but then condition
them out in the environments you don't want them to run it. i.e. by
adding a drop-in with "ConditionVirtualization=" or
"ConditionKernelCommandLine="... and so on.

Lennart

--
Lennart Poettering, Berlin
_______________________________________________
systemd-devel mailing list
systemd-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/systemd-devel