Re: How to use systemd-repart partitions?

[Lennart Poettering <lennart@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On Di, 19.05.20 23:05, Tobias Hunger (tobias.hunger@xxxxxxxxx) wrote:

> to partition the new drive. That works nicely. Now how do I format
> those partitions? Systemd-mkfs springs to mind -- so I will need to
> identify those partitions in /etc/fstab. My system is immutable, so I
> have to create /etc/fstab at the same time I create the various
> partition definition files in /usr/lib/repart.d.

So, yes, "systemd-makefs" was how I intended this originally to be
done. However, I think that's not going to suffice in the long run,
and instead systemd-repart will soon be able to format file systems
natively by invoking mkfs.<xyz>. For the following reasons:

1. Something I find particularly sexy: this way we can format the
   partitions before writing the partition table. This means if we get
   aborted in the middle the partition table will remain as it was
   before, and on next boot we can try again. This means formatted
   partitions can pop into existance at the moment the partition table
   is written and not a moment before, thus providing truly atomic
   behaviour where there's a clear point in time where nothing exists
   yet, and then suddenly everything exists, fully set up. This is how
   robust partitioning really should look like I think.

2. We should support setting up encryption, too. But if we do that,
   then x-systemd.makefs is not going to work anyway, because we need
   to do the LUKS stuff first, but if we do LUKS in repart, we might
   as well do mkfs.

3. This way we can also derive the fs UUIDs by hashing from the
   machine ID, like we already do for the partition UUIDs. which makes
   everything even more deterministic, which I like.

4. I want to cover the usecase where /usr/ is an immutable (verity
   verified even) image, and the root fs is created on first boot as
   writable fs, and then combined with /usr. This kind of setup means
   the initrd must already format the root fs, and x-systemd.makefs
   doesn't really cover that so nicely, since its run after the
   transition to the host fs.

Long story short: expect new settings FileSystemType= and Encrypt=
soon in /etc/repart.d/*.conf files soon. It's high on my TODO list.

> Would it maybe make sense to add a way to provide the partition UUID
> via the partitions .conf file as well? That way I would not need to
> add a UUID-part to my labels.

Yes, I guess we can make that available. Please file an RFE
issue. Even better, provide a patch!

Lennart

--
Lennart Poettering, Berlin
_______________________________________________
systemd-devel mailing list
systemd-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/systemd-devel