Here are some access.log excerpts when I try different operations : First I download from ftp.redhat.com the file abiword-1.0.4-2.i386.rpm (4.98 MB) (in binary mode) I get this line in access.log : 1106558551.810 14298 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 5232437 CONNECT ftp.redhat.com:14954 - DIRECT/209.132.176.30 - [Host: ftp.redhat.com:14954\r\n] [] and the download is correct. It works perfectly for every ftp download Then I try to upload a 79kB html file (in ascii mode) on my personal ftp account : firstly with smartftp : I get a 31.5 kB file on my ftp, with the following lines in access.log : 1106557992.094 43 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:36467 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:36467\r\n] [] 1106557992.154 15 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:54180 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:54180\r\n] [] If I retry, I get a 30.1 kB file 1106558060.515 43 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:29418 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:29418\r\n] [] 1106558060.571 18 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:63365 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:63365\r\n] [] Then a 42.6 kB file 1106558090.866 50 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:5221 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:5221\r\n] [] 1106558090.919 15 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:27894 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:27894\r\n] [] and a 31.5 kB file 1106558128.399 46 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:10667 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:10667\r\n] [] 1106558128.456 16 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:47718 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:47718\r\n] [] and a 53.6 kB file 1106558165.607 51 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:1246 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:1246\r\n] [] 1106558165.667 18 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:40582 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:40582\r\n] [] and a 50.9 kB file 1106558198.307 49 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:2186 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:2186\r\n] [] 1106558198.361 16 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:62871 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:62871\r\n] [] and a 28.7 kB file 1106558236.013 45 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:49806 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:49806\r\n] [] 1106558236.128 75 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:53424 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:53424\r\n] [] and so on... If I use filezilla instead of smartftp I get a 13.8 kB file 1106558918.549 23 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:45724 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:45724\r\n] [] 1106558918.629 10 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:5846 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:5846\r\n] [] then again a 13.8 kB file 1106559209.340 18 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:49877 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:49877\r\n] [] 1106559209.427 10 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 250 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:16455 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:16455\r\n] [] and so on Then I try to upload a 439 kB tgz binary file (in binary mode) At first with smartftp I get a 424 kB file 1106559593.377 208 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:41129 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:41129\r\n] [] 1106559593.489 19 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 313 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:50343 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:50343\r\n] [] then a 408 kB file 1106559690.549 210 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:55439 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:55439\r\n] [] 1106559690.660 16 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 313 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:18901 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:18901\r\n] [] and 382 kB file 1106559781.616 210 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:64826 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:64826\r\n] [] 1106559781.715 24 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 313 CONNECT ftpperso.free.fr:3442 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: ftpperso.free.fr:3442\r\n] [] If I try with filezilla, I get a 379 kB file 1106559871.045 351 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:60138 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:60138\r\n] [] 1106559871.192 12 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 313 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:35117 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:35117\r\n] [] then a 414 kB file 1106559926.912 12 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 313 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:53944 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:53944\r\n] [] 1106559929.764 172 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 39 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:44694 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:44694\r\n] [] 1106559929.860 11 192.168.1.3 TCP_MISS/200 313 CONNECT 212.27.40.252:24772 - DIRECT/212.27.40.252 - [Host: 212.27.40.252:24772\r\n] [] and so on... Does anyone have an idea ? Thanks Henri On Mon, 24 Jan 2005 07:48:48 +0100, Elsen Marc <elsen@xxxxxxx> wrote: > > > > > > Hello, > > > > I'm using Squid 2.5 STABLE6 (binary version from my Fedora Core 3), > > and I'm trying to make ftp upload work. > > Before I try to set more complex ACLs, I simply allowed anyone to > > access to everything (it's only for the first tests of course). > > I also commented the line that denied CONNECT to non ssl ports. > > > > The result of my first tests are : > > - no problem with HTTP download > > - no problem with HTTP upload > > - no problem with FTP download > > - but strange problem with FTP upload : > > I configured my ftp client (filezilla, opensource - cf > > filezilla.sf.net) to use an http proxy, I set the correct address and > > port, and then I successfully connected to an external ftp. > > My client correctly lists the files and folders on my ftp account, and > > I can succesfully download any files from this ftp. > > But, if I try to upload a file, it is transferred incompletely to the > > server, without any error message. The client thinks the transfer is > > ok, although it is obviously not. > > For example, when I try to upload a 79 kbytes html file, sometimes I > > get on the server side a 13 or 65 or 37 kbytes file, it doesn't > > truncate at the same size for each try with the same file. > > I get this problem whether I use ascii or binary mode. > > Same problem if I use smartftp instead of filezilla. > > I don't see any error in access.log (I can post it if necessary) > > And of course I don't limit the size of the transfers in squid.conf > > > > Does anybody have an idea of how to solve this problem ? > > > > I know that squid is not a true ftp proxy, but if this problem was > > solved, it would do everything that I need with ftp. Besides, I prefer > > not to use a distinct ftp proxy, because I intend to use squid with > > ldap authentication (with ldap groups and users), and with restricted > > ftp access (only a few people will have to use ftp upload, but this > > functionnality is required). > > > > > > What's in access.log for these failing http put requests ? > Compare the number of bytes transferred with the actual size of the file. > > Anything else in cache.log ? >
