On Wed, Mar 6, 2024, at 16:04, Christoph Hellwig wrote:
> On Wed, Mar 06, 2024 at 03:19:52PM +0100, Andreas Larsson wrote:
>> > I think that is the correct thing to do then: the only
>> > drivers that I see with this dependency are PCI sound cards
>> > that apparently rely on DMA to the 16MB ISA range, which is
>> > not provided by sparc.
>>
>> The ZONE_DMA dependency does not seem related to ISA per se. Commit
>> 80ab8eae70e5 ("ALSA: Enable CONFIG_ZONE_DMA for smaller PCI DMA masks")
>> that started to introduce it did were about ensuring 32-bit masks.
>
> Yikes! That commit is just unbelievable buggy. CONFIG_ZONE_DMA
> is only for architetures to select, not drivers. A driver randomly
> enabling such an arch zone is just crazy.
It looks like it did not remain that way for long, as
2db1a57986d3 ("ALSA: pci: depend on ZONE_DMA") removed
the broken select again.
> I've been wondering for a while if we need some Kconfig magic
> so that certain symbols can only be select from arch/* and not
> elsewhere to prevent this (we had a few other similar cases like
> DMA_MAP_OPS).
It's a nice idea, but it would require a lot of reworks to get right,
with things like drivers/platform/x86 or drivers/{parisc,s390,sh}
that are still somewhat architecture code, and subsystems like
drivers/gpu/drm that typically just select whatever they want
instead of using dependencies.
Arnd
