On Wed, Mar 1, 2023 at 9:33 AM James Carter <jwcart2@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > On Fri, Nov 25, 2022 at 10:51 AM Christian Göttsche > <cgzones@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > > > Signed-off-by: Christian Göttsche <cgzones@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> > > Acked-by: James Carter <jwcart2@xxxxxxxxx> > Merged. Thanks, Jim > > --- > > .../test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf | 369 ++++++++++++++++++ > > libsepol/tests/test-neverallow.c | 74 ++++ > > 2 files changed, 443 insertions(+) > > create mode 100644 libsepol/tests/policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf > > > > diff --git a/libsepol/tests/policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf b/libsepol/tests/policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf > > new file mode 100644 > > index 00000000..58a71059 > > --- /dev/null > > +++ b/libsepol/tests/policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf > > @@ -0,0 +1,369 @@ > > +class process > > +class blk_file > > +class chr_file > > +class dir > > +class fifo_file > > +class file > > +class lnk_file > > +class sock_file > > + > > +class class5 > > +class class6 > > +class class7 > > +class class17 > > + > > +sid kernel > > +sid security > > +sid unlabeled > > +sid file > > +sid port > > +sid netif > > +sid netmsg > > +sid node > > +sid devnull > > + > > +class process { dyntransition transition } > > +class file { ioctl read write } > > + > > +class class5 { perm } > > +class class6 { perm } > > +class class7 { perm } > > +class class17 { ioctl } > > + > > +ifdef(`enable_mls',` > > +sensitivity s0; > > +dominance { s0 } > > +category c0; category c1; category c2; category c3; > > +category c4; category c5; category c6; category c7; > > +category c8; category c9; category c10; category c11; > > +category c12; category c13; category c14; category c15; > > +category c16; category c17; category c18; category c19; > > +category c20; category c21; category c22; category c23; > > + > > +level s0:c0.c23; > > + > > +mlsconstrain file { write } ( h1 dom h2 ); > > +') > > + > > + > > +######################################## > > +# > > +# Test start > > +# > > +######################################## > > + > > + > > +## Test 1 (single type) > > + > > +type test1_t; > > +allow test1_t test1_t : file read; > > +neverallow test1_t { test1_t -self } : file read; # nofail > > + > > + > > +## Test 2 (single type) > > + > > +type test2_t; > > +allow test2_t self : file read; > > +neverallow test2_t { test1_t -self } : file read; # nofail > > + > > +## Test 3 (single type) > > + > > +type test3_1_t; > > +type test3_2_t; > > +allow test3_1_t test3_2_t : file read; > > +neverallow test3_1_t { test3_2_t -self } : file read; > > + > > + > > +## Test 4 (two types I) > > + > > +type test4_1_t; > > +type test4_2_t; > > +allow { test4_1_t test4_2_t } { test4_1_t test4_2_t } : file read; > > +neverallow test4_1_t { test4_1_t test4_2_t -self } : file read; > > + > > + > > +## Test 5 (two types II) > > + > > +type test5_1_t; > > +type test5_2_t; > > +allow { test5_1_t test5_2_t } { test5_1_t test5_2_t } : class5 perm; > > +neverallow * { test5_1_t test5_2_t -self } : class5 perm; > > + > > + > > +## Test 6 (two types III) > > + > > +type test6_1_t; > > +type test6_2_t; > > +allow { test6_1_t test6_2_t } { test6_1_t test6_2_t } : class6 perm; > > +neverallow * { test6_2_t -self } : class6 perm; > > + > > + > > +## Test 7 (two types IV) > > + > > +type test7_1_t; > > +type test7_2_t; > > +allow { test7_1_t test7_2_t } test7_2_t : class7 perm; > > +neverallow * { test7_1_t -self } : class7 perm; # nofail > > + > > + > > +## Test 8 (attribute violates type I) > > + > > +attribute test8_a; > > +type test8_1_t, test8_a; > > +type test8_2_t, test8_a; > > +allow test8_a test8_a : file read; > > +neverallow test8_1_t { test8_a -self } : file *; > > + > > + > > +## Test 9 (attribute violates type II) > > + > > +attribute test9_a; > > +type test9_1_t, test9_a; > > +type test9_2_t, test9_a; > > +allow test9_1_t test9_a : file read; > > +neverallow test9_1_t { test9_a -self } : file *; > > + > > + > > +## Test 10 (attribute violates type III) > > + > > +attribute test10_1_a; > > +attribute test10_2_a; > > +type test10_1_t, test10_1_a, test10_1_a; > > +type test10_2_t, test10_1_a, test10_1_a; > > +allow test10_1_a test10_1_a : file read; > > +neverallow test10_1_t { test10_2_a -self } : file *; > > + > > + > > +## Test 11 (attribute violates attribute I) > > + > > +attribute test11_1_a; > > +attribute test11_2_a; > > +type test11_1_t, test11_1_a, test11_2_a; > > +type test11_2_t, test11_1_a, test11_2_a; > > +allow test11_1_t self : file read; > > +allow test11_2_t test11_2_t : file read; > > +neverallow test11_1_a { test11_2_a -self } : file *; # nofail > > + > > + > > +## Test 12 (attribute violates attribute II) > > + > > +attribute test12_a; > > +type test12_1_t, test12_a; > > +type test12_2_t, test12_a; > > +allow test12_1_t test12_2_t : file read; > > +neverallow test12_a { test12_a -self } : file *; > > + > > + > > +## Test 13 (attribute violates attribute III) > > + > > +attribute test13_a; > > +type test13_1_t, test13_a; > > +type test13_2_t, test13_a; > > +allow test13_1_t test13_a : file read; > > +neverallow test13_a { test13_a -self } : file *; > > + > > + > > +## Test 14 (attribute violates attribute IV) > > + > > +attribute test14_a; > > +type test14_1_t, test14_a; > > +type test14_2_t, test14_a; > > +allow test14_a test14_a : file read; > > +neverallow test14_a { test14_a -self } : file *; > > + > > + > > +# ## Test 15 (attribute violates attribute V) > > + > > +attribute test13_1_a; > > +attribute test13_2_a; > > +type test13_t, test13_1_a, test13_2_a; > > +allow test13_1_a test13_2_a : file read; > > +neverallow test13_a { test13_2_a -self } : file *; > > + > > + > > +## Test 16 (types violate attribute) > > + > > +attribute test16_a; > > +type test16_1_t, test16_a; > > +type test16_2_t, test16_a; > > +allow { test16_1_t test16_2_t } { test16_1_t test16_2_t } : file read; > > +neverallow test16_a { test16_a -self } : file ~write; > > + > > + > > +## Test 17 (extended permissions I) > > + > > +type test17_1_t; > > +type test17_2_t; > > +allow { test17_1_t test17_2_t } { test17_1_t test17_2_t } : class17 ioctl; > > +neverallowxperm ~test17_2_t { test17_1_t test17_2_t -self } : class17 ioctl 0x1111; > > + > > + > > +## Test 18 (extended permissions II) > > + > > +type test18_1_t; > > +type test18_2_t; > > +allow { test18_1_t test18_2_t } { test18_1_t test18_2_t } : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm { test18_1_t test18_2_t } { test18_1_t test18_2_t } : file ioctl 0x1111; > > +neverallowxperm { test18_1_t test18_2_t } { test18_1_t test18_2_t -self } : file ioctl 0x2222; # nofail > > + > > + > > +## Test 19 (extended permissions III) > > + > > +type test19_1_t; > > +type test19_2_t; > > +allow { test19_1_t test19_2_t } { test19_1_t test19_2_t } : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm { test19_1_t test19_2_t } { test19_1_t test19_2_t } : file ioctl { 0x0100 - 0x0102 }; > > +neverallowxperm test19_2_t { test19_1_t test19_2_t -self } : file ioctl { 0x0101 - 0x0104 }; > > + > > + > > +## Test 20 (extended permissions IV) > > + > > +type test20_1_t; > > +type test20_2_t; > > +allow { test20_1_t test20_2_t } { test20_1_t test20_2_t } : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test20_1_t test20_1_t : file ioctl 0x0101; > > +allowxperm test20_1_t test20_2_t : file ioctl 0x0102; > > +allowxperm test20_2_t test20_1_t : file ioctl 0x0103; > > +allowxperm test20_2_t test20_2_t : file ioctl 0x0104; > > +neverallowxperm { test20_1_t test20_2_t } { test20_1_t test20_2_t -self } : file ioctl { 0x0000 - 0x9000 }; > > + > > + > > +## Test 21 (extended permissions V) > > + > > +attribute test21_a; > > +type test21_1_t, test21_a; > > +type test21_2_t, test21_a; > > +allow test21_a test21_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test21_a test21_a : file ioctl 0x9501; > > +neverallowxperm test21_1_t { test21_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9511; # nofail > > + > > + > > +## Test 22 (extended permissions VI) > > + > > +type test22_t; > > +allow test22_t self : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test22_t self : file ioctl 0x9501; > > +allowxperm test22_t self : file ioctl 0x9511; > > +neverallowxperm test22_t { test22_t -self } : file ioctl 0x9511; # nofail > > + > > + > > +## Test 23 (extended permissions VII) > > + > > +attribute test23_a; > > +type test23_1_t, test23_a; > > +type test23_2_t, test23_a; > > +allow test23_a test23_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test23_a test23_a : file ioctl 0x9501; > > +allowxperm test23_1_t test23_2_t : file ioctl 0x9511; > > +neverallowxperm test23_1_t { test23_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9511; > > + > > + > > +## Test 24 (extended permissions VII) > > + > > +attribute test24_a; > > +type test24_1_t, test24_a; > > +type test24_2_t, test24_a; > > +allow test24_a test24_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test24_a test24_a : file ioctl 0x9501; > > +allowxperm test24_1_t test24_a : file ioctl 0x9511; > > +neverallowxperm test24_1_t { test24_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9511; > > + > > + > > +## Test 25 (extended permissions IX) > > + > > +attribute test25_a; > > +type test25_1_t, test25_a; > > +type test25_2_t, test25_a; > > +allow test25_a test25_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test25_a test25_a : file ioctl 0x9501; > > +allowxperm test25_a test25_a : file ioctl 0x9511; > > +neverallowxperm test25_1_t { test25_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9511; > > + > > + > > +## Test 26 (extended permissions X) > > + > > +attribute test26_1_a; > > +attribute test26_2_a; > > +type test26_1_t, test26_1_a, test26_2_a; > > +type test26_2_t, test26_1_a, test26_2_a; > > +allow { test26_1_a test26_2_a } { test26_1_a test26_2_a } : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm { test26_1_a test26_2_a } { test26_1_a test26_2_a } : file ioctl 0x9501; > > +allowxperm test26_1_a test26_2_a : file ioctl 0x9511; > > +neverallowxperm test26_1_t { test26_2_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9511; > > + > > + > > +# ## Test 27 (extended permissions attribute violation I) > > + > > +attribute test27_a; > > +type test27_1_t, test27_a; > > +type test27_2_t, test27_a; > > +allow test27_a test27_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test27_a test27_a : file ioctl 0x9501; > > +allowxperm test27_1_t self : file ioctl 0x9521; > > +allowxperm test27_2_t test27_2_t : file ioctl 0x9521; > > +neverallowxperm test27_a { test27_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9521; # nofail > > + > > + > > +# ## Test 28 (extended permissions attribute violation II) > > + > > +attribute test28_a; > > +type test28_1_t, test28_a; > > +type test28_2_t, test28_a; > > +allow test28_a test28_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test28_1_t test28_2_t : file ioctl 0x9521; > > +neverallowxperm test28_a { test28_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9521; > > + > > + > > +## Test 29 (extended permissions attribute violation III) > > + > > +attribute test29_a; > > +type test29_1_t, test29_a; > > +type test29_2_t, test29_a; > > +allow test29_a test29_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test29_1_t test29_a : file ioctl 0x9521; > > +neverallowxperm test29_a { test29_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9521; > > + > > + > > +## Test 30 (extended permissions attribute violation IV) > > + > > +attribute test30_a; > > +type test30_1_t, test30_a; > > +type test30_2_t, test30_a; > > +allow test30_a test30_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test30_a test30_a : file ioctl 0x9521; > > +neverallowxperm test30_a { test30_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9521; > > + > > + > > +## Test 31 (extended permissions attribute violation V) > > + > > +attribute test31_1_a; > > +attribute test31_2_a; > > +type test31_1_t, test31_1_a, test31_2_a; > > +type test31_2_t, test31_1_a, test31_2_a; > > +allow test31_1_a test31_1_a : file ioctl; > > +allowxperm test31_1_a test31_2_a : file ioctl 0x9521; > > +neverallowxperm test31_1_a { test31_2_a -self } : file ioctl 0x9521; > > + > > + > > +######################################## > > +# > > +# Test End > > +# > > +######################################## > > + > > + > > +type sys_isid; > > +role sys_role; > > +role sys_role types sys_isid; > > +gen_user(sys_user,, sys_role, s0, s0 - s0:c0.c23) > > +sid kernel gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +sid security gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +sid unlabeled gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +sid file gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +sid port gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +sid netif gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +sid netmsg gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +sid node gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +sid devnull gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0) > > +fs_use_trans devpts gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0); > > +fs_use_trans devtmpfs gen_context(sys_user:sys_role:sys_isid, s0); > > diff --git a/libsepol/tests/test-neverallow.c b/libsepol/tests/test-neverallow.c > > index c6518ebb..c0a2bfa8 100644 > > --- a/libsepol/tests/test-neverallow.c > > +++ b/libsepol/tests/test-neverallow.c > > @@ -154,6 +154,75 @@ static void test_neverallow_basic(void) > > policydb_destroy(&base_expanded); > > } > > > > +static void test_neverallow_minus_self(void) > > +{ > > + policydb_t basemod, base_expanded; > > + sepol_handle_t *handle; > > + static const char *const expected_messages[] = { > > + "33 neverallow failures occurred", > > + "neverallow on line 77 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 77 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test3_1_t test3_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 85 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 85 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test4_1_t test4_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 93 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 93 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test5_1_t test5_2_t:class5 { perm };", > > + "neverallow on line 93 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 93 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test5_2_t test5_1_t:class5 { perm };", > > + "neverallow on line 101 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 101 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test6_1_t test6_2_t:class6 { perm };", > > + "neverallow on line 118 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 118 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test8_1_t test8_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 127 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 127 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test9_1_t test9_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 137 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 137 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test10_1_t test10_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 157 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 157 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test12_1_t test12_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 166 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 166 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test13_1_t test13_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 175 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 175 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test14_1_t test14_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 175 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 175 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test14_2_t test14_1_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 193 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 193 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test16_1_t test16_2_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallow on line 193 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 193 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by allow test16_2_t test16_1_t:file { read };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 201 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 201 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallow test17_1_t test17_2_t:class17 { ioctl };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 219 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 219 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test19_2_t test19_1_t:file ioctl { 0x101-0x102 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 231 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 231 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test20_1_t test20_2_t:file ioctl { 0x102 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 231 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 231 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test20_2_t test20_1_t:file ioctl { 0x103 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 261 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 261 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test23_1_t test23_2_t:file ioctl { 0x9511 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 272 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 272 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test24_1_t test24_a:file ioctl { 0x9511 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 283 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 283 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test25_a test25_a:file ioctl { 0x9511 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 295 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 295 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test26_1_a test26_2_a:file ioctl { 0x9511 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 295 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 295 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test26_1_a test26_2_a:file ioctl { 0x9511 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 295 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 295 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test26_1_a test26_2_a:file ioctl { 0x9511 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 295 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 295 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test26_1_a test26_2_a:file ioctl { 0x9511 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 317 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 317 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test28_1_t test28_2_t:file ioctl { 0x9521 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 317 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 317 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallow test28_2_t test28_1_t:file { ioctl };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 327 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 327 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test29_1_t test29_a:file ioctl { 0x9521 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 327 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 327 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallow test29_2_t test29_1_t:file { ioctl };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 337 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 337 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test30_a test30_a:file ioctl { 0x9521 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 337 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 337 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test30_a test30_a:file ioctl { 0x9521 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 348 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 348 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test31_1_a test31_2_a:file ioctl { 0x9521 };", > > + "neverallowxperm on line 348 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std (or line 348 of policies/test-neverallow/policy_minus_self.conf.std) violated by\nallowxperm test31_1_a test31_2_a:file ioctl { 0x9521 };", > > + }; > > + > > + if (policydb_init(&base_expanded)) > > + CU_FAIL_FATAL("Failed to initialize policy"); > > + > > + if (test_load_policy(&basemod, POLICY_BASE, mls, "test-neverallow", "policy_minus_self.conf")) > > + CU_FAIL_FATAL("Failed to load policy"); > > + > > + if (link_modules(NULL, &basemod, NULL, 0, 0)) > > + CU_FAIL_FATAL("Failed to link base module"); > > + > > + if (expand_module(NULL, &basemod, &base_expanded, 0, 0)) > > + CU_FAIL_FATAL("Failed to expand policy"); > > + > > + if ((handle = sepol_handle_create()) == NULL) > > + CU_FAIL_FATAL("Failed to initialize handle"); > > + > > + sepol_msg_set_callback(handle, msg_handler, NULL); > > + > > + if (check_assertions(handle, &base_expanded, base_expanded.global->branch_list->avrules) != -1) > > + CU_FAIL("Assertions did not trigger"); > > + > > + messages_check(ARRAY_SIZE(expected_messages), expected_messages); > > + > > + sepol_handle_destroy(handle); > > + messages_clean(); > > + policydb_destroy(&basemod); > > + policydb_destroy(&base_expanded); > > +} > > + > > static void test_neverallow_not_self(void) > > { > > policydb_t basemod, base_expanded; > > @@ -243,5 +312,10 @@ int neverallow_add_tests(CU_pSuite suite) > > return CU_get_error(); > > } > > > > + if (NULL == CU_add_test(suite, "neverallow_minus_self", test_neverallow_minus_self)) { > > + CU_cleanup_registry(); > > + return CU_get_error(); > > + } > > + > > return 0; > > } > > -- > > 2.38.1 > >