This is great info. We are having this problem on a RHEL5 server with 8gb of ram (32bits) since some time ago. I understand that the hugemem kernel is no longer available in RHEL5, so we installed the PAE kernel but it makes no difference, we still have the oom. 64bits is not an option at the moment, so if i understand correctly, using just 4gb of ram instead of the 8gb that we currently have, could potentially solve the oom-killer problem ? cheers, C. On 8/10/07, Eric Sisler <esisler@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > Hi Manuel, > > > The fact of having large amounts of memory is important? I mean, this > > can happen either with 2GB or 10GB? > > Yes. More total RAM = more low memory required to map high memory > usage. This problem never occurred here on older servers with 6Gb or > RAM or less, even on those with many virtual machines running. The > first time it happened here was on a server with 8Gb RAM. > > > It´s just curiosity, I have never ever faced this problem. I found > > this topic really interesting, though > > "Interesting" is only one of the words I used while trying to solve the > problem... <grin> > > > Does hugemen act as a module or...? How can it expand the low memory? > > It's a different kernel that splits low & high memory differently. On a > server with 8Gb RAM: > > Kernel HighTotal LowTotal MemTotal > ---------------------------------------------- > regular 7470840 kB 837724 kB 8308564 kB > hugemem 5242872 kB 3063376 kB 8306248 kB > > Notice that low memory took a significant jump when running the hugemem > kernel, at the expense of high memory. Total memory is also a bit > smaller, probably due to overhead imposed by the hugemem kernel. > > > If the first solution, your point was to upgrade to 64-bit. And as you > > wrote, if you even run out of low memory...pray. > > What if you do the vm.lower_zone_protection = 250 ? Should it give you > > some more "extra time" before the disaster? > > There really isn't any need for lower_zone_protection when using the 64- > bit kernel as *all* memory is lower memory. Same 8Gb server with the > 64-bit kernel running: > > HighTotal: 0 kB > LowTotal: 8162488 kB > MemTotal: 8162488 kB > > > Really interesting post, Eric. > > Glad you found it interesting. > > > Eventually, what did you do? Upgrade? Disable oom-killer? Pray? Delete > > VMWare server? :-) > > 1) Upgrade to 64-bit for newer servers. > 2) Run the hugemem kernel on older servers with 6Gb or more of RAM. > > No further problems encountered. :-) > > -Eric > > -- > Eric Sisler <esisler@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> > Library Network Specialist > Westminster Public Library > Westminster, CO USA > > Linux - Don't fear the Penguin. > Want to know what we use Linux for? > Visit http://wallace.westminster.lib.co.us/linux > > -- > redhat-list mailing list > unsubscribe mailto:redhat-list-request@xxxxxxxxxx?subject=unsubscribe > https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list > -- redhat-list mailing list unsubscribe mailto:redhat-list-request@xxxxxxxxxx?subjecthttps://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list
