On Mon, May 16, 2022 at 11:43:48AM +0200, Vit Kabele wrote:
> And the valid upper bound of the EBDA pointer is also different
> for these two use-cases. (The mpparse.c usage is interested in EBDA
> pointer only if it ends 1KiB before the end of low memory, while the
> ebda.c accepts even the values in the last KiB below 640KiB).
And I still don't know why this difference in the upper bounds is really
relevant and why you can't simply use the code in reserve_bios_regions()
after carving it out in a helper?
The latter considers ebda_start valid when it is between BIOS_START_MIN
and bios_start, after having sanitized that bios_start to 640K if "out
of bounds".
Why can't default_find_smp_config() simply scan the last KiB below
640KiB twice for the sake of simpler code?
I.e., there needs to be a single get_bios_ebda() - the current one can
be renamed to __get_bios_ebda() - and that get_bios_ebda() should give
either a sane EBDA address or 0 if the checks don't pass. And all code
should use that.
--
Regards/Gruss,
Boris.
https://people.kernel.org/tglx/notes-about-netiquette
