Thanks guys now I need to figure out the PHP code on this. It's a real pain when you use a text book as an example and there are unexplained bugs. I will report this to Wiley Press. ----- Original Message ----- From: Pete To: php-objects@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Sent: Monday, August 10, 2009 5:12 PM Subject: Re: mysql problem in a php book In message <A26BE5D4-B399-432F-8462-B9F2B24175A0@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, Joe Forsythe <jforsythe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> writes >What is your question/what problem are you having? >-- >Joe Hey, Joe, as I read the original, I thought, great, we have all the details we need for once... <G> He did say >> Message d'erreur : Unknown column 'a.type_id' in 'on clause' 1) You have create_date rather than creation_date 2) The tables are in the wrong order for a JOIN - in the FROM section, I have swapped a c for c a SELECT a.name, a.type_id, b.title, b.description, b.content_date, b.creation_date, b.created_by, b.last_upd_date, b.last_upd_by, c.name as dept_name, content_id FROM Department c, Content_Type a LEFT OUTER JOIN Content b on a.type_id = b.content_type and a.type_id = b.content_type and b.dept_id = 3 and b.content_type = 4 WHERE c.dept_id = 3 ORDER BY content_date DESC And I get 4 records returned. They may not be the right ones, but... -- Pete Clark Hot Costa - Local Spain http://www.hotcosta.com [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]