Richard Lynch wrote:
On Tue, April 25, 2006 12:47 pm, Stut wrote:
As long as we're throwing foreign money into the ring, I'd just like
to
say that I make a point of redirecting to another page after a post
request, otherwise you get unsightly errors in the browser when the
user
tries to use the back/forward buttons. Other than in that situation I
make sure I do includes rather than redirects.
There are viable alternatives to breaking the back button...
Not to mention that it's sometimes VERY useful to be able to use a
browser that lets one re-submit a form with altered data with the back
button, rather than going through the process from the beginning.
Though that is application-specific.
Indeed, but that's not the issue. Consider these sequences...
1) User fills in form and submits it
2) Form action script processes the form and simply outputs the page
Then either...
3a) User hits back... form gets shown, hopefully (dependant on
browser/cache settings) with the data the user had entered previously on
it - No bad stuff here
or...
3b) User clicks on a normal link, goes to another page then hits back...
user sees an evil-looking and unexpected question asking whether to
resubmit the form values. Most users I know will hit OK because they
don't understand it. This is bad, form gets submitted again. In the case
where they hit cancel instead they end up with an error message and have
effectively left your site... also very bad.
Better...
1) User fills in form and submits it
2) Form action script processes the form and redirects to the next page
As before, either...
3a) User hits back... same thing as before happens, form is displayed
hopefully with previously entered data
or...
3b) User clicks on a normal link, then hits back... since the post page
never ended up in the browser history this action has the same effect as
in 3a, showing the form hopefully with previously entered data. If the
user then submits the form again that's their choice, but in theory at
least it's a better informed choice than the previous scenario.
In my most humble opinion, any post handler that doesn't do a redirect
after processing the form is bad. Hope that made sense.
-Stut
--
PHP General Mailing List (http://www.php.net/)
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php
