Emily wrote: > > Pini Vollach - SunSet Too much water. Not enough saturation. Could be sharper. Thank you Emily for your review. Usually I try to learn from the reviews and not to argue with them. I even angry on those who argue because I think they miss the message. But here, I think my message about the conditions this was shot, was missed. This image was shot on a tripod at 20:45 hr. f=300 mm on EOS450 (X1.6 = 480 mm) This is night time. (Although you see a big sun, it was quite dark). Ok Too much water - No argue. Not enough saturation - Much much more than what came out of the camera. Could be sharper - What? I examined it again, clouds are sharp, foreground is sharp, you probably mean the moving water? I don't think this is one of my best images, not at all, but I wrote about how I feel with sunsets and with this one. This is probably only me. About the technical POV, this image cannot be judged like a regular sunset image which done in much more lighted ambience. Chris wrote: The sunset is unremarkable. Thank you for this short review. I thought it is a different kind of sunset image. I didn't want to impress. I did want to deliver some kind of atmosphere. I guess it didn't work. Pini
