Search Postgresql Archives

Re: OT: Canadian Tax Database

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 




And due at least in part to government (and other institutions operated by damned fools) opting for the least expensive provider rather than paying for
someone who actually knows what they're doing.  Just as buying cheap junk
always comes back to get you, hiring incompetent fools that don't know their
ass from a hole in the ground will come back to get you too.

What you describe is a hundred times better than the reality... most of
them actually get _expensive_ junk with some kick-back ;-)

I concede.

You're right.

I recall being told by one project manager I knew years ago who had an opportunity to create a bid for an RFP issued by Transport Canada (long long ago). He refuse, so his employer prepared the bid. He refused because the RFP was a joke. There were absolutely no functional requirements, nor non-functional requirements, identified in the RFP. His company didn't get the contract, but being a bidder they did see the winning bid. It was just as ludicrous! It, too, failed to identify any requirements, and so it did not actually promise to deliver anything, working or not! They would have satisfied the terms of their contract if, after a few years, and hundreds of man-years, they walked away without delivering anything. That tragedy cost Canada hundreds of millions, if not billions, of dollars (I don't know if any final accounting was ever done - that would be opposed by the "civil servants" responsible lest they should be criticised for their incompetence), and ultimately nothing was delivered because the next elected government cancelled the project, refusing to through more money into their opposition's money pit - they prefer, of course, to through it into money pits created by their political supporters. The decisions to create the project, and to cancel it, were political, but the incompetence really responsible for it was lower done within the ranks of the civil service. The project could have delivered something good had the civil servants involved been competent! Similar nonsense happened with the firearms registry. For most of the early history of it, the software systems used where so bad, and inappropriate, that the clerks that had to use it could have been ten times more productive if they had the use of properly designed and implemented software. I can not understand how it became so outrageously expensive when the real needs for it were so simple (relative to products I have worked on). I'll bet real, genuinely capable, software engineers could have delivered a gold and platinum plated product for just a few million dollars; nothing really relative to what it ended up costing us.

I know contractors that refuse to do business with the government because of this sort of nonsense, and I know, from discussions with ex-civil servants, that such incompetence is the norm in government. I know engineers who have been burned by government by investing a fortune in new products or services, and then educating relevant civil servants WRT to the new science or technology involved, only to find these same civil servants give contracts to provide the new product or service to incompetent bozos who didn't know the first thing about it. They just happened to be cheaper. Why waste time and money developing a product or service that is really relevant only to government when the risk of such unethical conduct by government is so high?

I don't support anyone out there can describe a project or three where things were done right, to provide a cure for the depressing and discouraging nature of what this thread has turned out to be?

Cheers

Ted



[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[Index of Archives]     [Postgresql Jobs]     [Postgresql Admin]     [Postgresql Performance]     [Linux Clusters]     [PHP Home]     [PHP on Windows]     [Kernel Newbies]     [PHP Classes]     [PHP Books]     [PHP Databases]     [Postgresql & PHP]     [Yosemite]
  Powered by Linux