On Wed, Apr 20, 2005 at 12:49:15PM +0200, Anders Fugmann wrote: > Hi, > > I would like to request a very simple feature: The possibility to lock > all iptable rules in the kernel, making them immutable. > > This would be usefull on machines which act both as a firewall and as a > server. The problem today if an unwanted guest manages to break into the > machine running the firewall and becomes root, the person can easilly > change the rules, compromising the network guarded by the hacked > firewall. > > If it was somehow possible to lock the rules once setup, the attacker > would be unable to modify the rules, the network guarded by the firewall > would not (pending on how the firewall was setup) not be compromised, > even if an attacker gained access to the firewall itself. i'm guessing you're thinking about how the *BSD's have a concept of kern.securelevel, and certain things (like firewall rules) become immutable; even by root, at certain levels. i'm not a kernel programmer, but i can tell you that the linux kernel doesn't have anything like kern.securelevel; and without it, i don't believe what you're asking for is possible. i'd also figure that implementing kern.securelevel in the linux kernel would be beyond the scope of what the netfilter developers are responsible for. -j -- "Stewie: Careful! You're washing a baby's scalp, not scrubbing the vomit out of a Christmas dress, you stupid holiday drunk." --Family Guy