Hi, I skimmed through nft man page and noted down problems I discovered. While doing so, I got the idea to restructure the whole document for better organization and comprehensibility but wanted to hear your thoughts first before creating a ticket in netfilter BZ: * Use BNF in synopses This is rudimentally used in the SYNOPSIS section already, but just lists _cmd_ without explanation - although the fun is only about to start at this point. :) What I really don't like is the syntax used in e.g. CHAINS section: it is not only imprecise (nothing says you have to use 'priority <prio>' but may not use 'table <table>', but also plain wrong when it comes to the mandatory braces around the chain_block. * Organize entity descriptions BNF-style In my opinion the order of (sub-)sections is a bit chaotic at times. E.g. RULES section synopsis tries to explain how a rule is made up from statements, but these are not explained before five sections later (not counting the bogus BLA section ;). The idea here is to go from most generic to most specific, like things are defined in yacc - just not as explicit, since if I want to know the relation between concat_rhs_expr and shift_rhs_expr, I can just as well read the code itself. * What about sub-pages? Looking at some expressions' descriptions, it seems like these might grow exponentially with the documentation improving. So maybe it makes sense to follow iptables' advice and have 'nft-extensions.8'? I would have called it 'nft-statements.8' or 'nft-expressions.8' but the two are too much intertwined to keep them separate. OK, maybe this can wait until nft.8 really has become awfully long. Comments, flame, donations highly appreciated, of course! Cheers, Phil -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe netfilter-devel" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
