OK. Here it is. Please look for III=0 and subsequent res=0. <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_new: sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004184065 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=0 maxend=0 maxwin=0 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_in_window: START <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.060000] seq=4004184064 ack=0+(0) sack=0+(0) win=1500 end=4004184065 <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_in_window: sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004184065 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=0 maxend=0 maxwin=0 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.060000] seq=4004184064 ack=0+(0) sack=0+(0) win=1500 end=4004184065 <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_in_window: sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004184065 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=0 maxend=0 maxwin=0 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=1 IV=1 <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_in_window: res=1 sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004184065 maxwin=1500 receiver end=0 maxend=1500 maxwin=0 <7>[ 2238.060000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.060000] syn=1 ack=0 fin=0 rst=0 old=0 new=1 <7>[ 2238.110000] tcp_in_window: START <7>[ 2238.110000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.110000] seq=201772607 ack=4004184065+(0) sack=4004184065+(0) win=14600 end=201772608 <7>[ 2238.110000] tcp_in_window: sender end=0 maxend=1500 maxwin=0 scale=0 receiver end=4004184065 maxend=4004184065 maxwin=1500 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.110000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.110000] seq=201772607 ack=4004184065+(0) sack=4004184065+(0) win=14600 end=201772608 <7>[ 2238.110000] tcp_in_window: sender end=201772608 maxend=201772608 maxwin=14600 scale=0 receiver end=4004184065 maxend=4004184065 maxwin=1500 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.110000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=1 IV=1 <7>[ 2238.110000] tcp_in_window: res=1 sender end=201772608 maxend=201772608 maxwin=14600 receiver end=4004184065 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 <7>[ 2238.110000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.110000] syn=1 ack=1 fin=0 rst=0 old=1 new=2 <7>[ 2238.120000] tcp_in_window: START <7>[ 2238.120000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.120000] seq=4004184065 ack=201772608+(0) sack=201772608+(0) win=1500 end=4004184065 <7>[ 2238.120000] tcp_in_window: sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=201772608 maxend=201772608 maxwin=14600 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.120000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.120000] seq=4004184065 ack=201772608+(0) sack=201772608+(0) win=1500 end=4004184065 <7>[ 2238.120000] tcp_in_window: sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=201772608 maxend=201772608 maxwin=14600 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.120000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=1 IV=1 <7>[ 2238.120000] tcp_in_window: res=1 sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 receiver end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 <7>[ 2238.120000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.120000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=0 rst=0 old=2 new=3 <7>[ 2238.810000] tcp_in_window: START <7>[ 2238.810000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.810000] seq=4004184065 ack=201772608+(0) sack=201772608+(0) win=1500 end=4004184095 <7>[ 2238.810000] tcp_in_window: sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.810000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.810000] seq=4004184065 ack=201772608+(0) sack=201772608+(0) win=1500 end=4004184095 <7>[ 2238.810000] tcp_in_window: sender end=4004184065 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.810000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=1 IV=1 <7>[ 2238.810000] tcp_in_window: res=1 sender end=4004184095 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 receiver end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 <7>[ 2238.810000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.810000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=0 rst=0 old=3 new=3 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: START <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.870000] seq=201772608 ack=4004184095+(0) sack=4004184095+(0) win=14600 end=201772608 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: sender end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 scale=0 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.870000] seq=201772608 ack=4004184095+(0) sack=4004184095+(0) win=14600 end=201772608 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: sender end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 scale=0 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198665 maxwin=1500 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=1 IV=1 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: res=1 sender end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.870000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=0 rst=0 old=3 new=3 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: START <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.870000] seq=201772608 ack=4004184095+(0) sack=4004184095+(0) win=14600 end=201772626 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: sender end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 scale=0 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.870000] seq=201772608 ack=4004184095+(0) sack=4004184095+(0) win=14600 end=201772626 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: sender end=201772608 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 scale=0 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=1 IV=1 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_in_window: res=1 sender end=201772626 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.870000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=0 rst=0 old=3 new=3 <7>[ 2238.870000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.870000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=3 new=4 <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_in_window: START <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.880000] seq=4004184095 ack=201772626+(0) sack=201772626+(0) win=1500 end=4004184095 <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_in_window: sender end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=201772626 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.880000] seq=4004184095 ack=201772626+(0) sack=201772626+(0) win=1500 end=4004184095 <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_in_window: sender end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 scale=0 receiver end=201772626 maxend=201774108 maxwin=14600 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=1 IV=1 <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_in_window: res=1 sender end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 receiver end=201772626 maxend=201774126 maxwin=14600 <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.880000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=0 rst=0 old=4 new=5 <7>[ 2238.880000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2238.880000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=5 new=6 <7>[ 2238.940000] tcp_in_window: START <7>[ 2238.940000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.940000] seq=201772627 ack=4004184096+(0) sack=4004184096+(0) win=14600 end=201772627 <7>[ 2238.940000] tcp_in_window: sender end=201772626 maxend=201774126 maxwin=14600 scale=0 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.940000] tcp_in_window: <7>[ 2238.940000] seq=201772626 ack=4004184096+(0) sack=4004184096+(0) win=14600 end=201772626 <7>[ 2238.940000] tcp_in_window: sender end=201772626 maxend=201774126 maxwin=14600 scale=0 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 scale=0 <7>[ 2238.940000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=0 IV=1 <7>[ 2238.940000] tcp_in_window: res=0 sender end=201772626 maxend=201774126 maxwin=14600 receiver end=4004184095 maxend=4004198695 maxwin=1500 <7>[ 2238.940000] nf_ct_tcp: invalid new deleting. <7>[ 2241.930000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2241.930000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2244.990000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2244.990000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2248.060000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2248.060000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2251.120000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2251.120000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2254.190000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2254.190000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2257.250000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2257.250000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2260.320000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2260.320000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2263.380000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2263.380000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2266.440000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2266.440000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2269.510000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2269.510000] syn=0 ack=1 fin=1 rst=0 old=6 new=6 <7>[ 2272.570000] tcp_conntracks: <7>[ 2272.570000] syn=0 ack=0 fin=0 rst=1 old=6 new=8 On Tue, Oct 21, 2014 at 1:39 PM, Jozsef Kadlecsik <kadlec@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > On Tue, 21 Oct 2014, vDev wrote: > >> Thanks, Jozsef. I see sequence number compensation in >> segment_seq_plus_len() but does that not cover the ACK sequence >> numbers. The variables (sack and receiver->td_end) are off by 1. It >> seems like receiver->td_end must be incremented by 1 for last ACK. >> Here's a trace: >> >> [ 775.980000] seq=726609914 ack=94044192+(0) sack=94044192+(0) >> win=14600 end=726609914 >> [ 775.980000] tcp_in_window: sender end=726609914 maxend=726611414 >> maxwin=14600 scale=0 receiver end=94044191 maxend=94058791 maxwin=1500 >> scale=0 >> [ 775.980000] tcp_in_window: I=1 II=1 III=0 IV=1 >> [ 775.980000] tcp_in_window: res=0 sender end=726609914 >> maxend=726611414 maxwin=14600 receiver end=94044191 maxend=94058791 >> maxwin=1500 >> >> As you can see above sack is 94044192 and receiver end is 94044191. As >> a result III is 0 and res=0 which causes -NF_ACCEPT to be returned. > > It's a single packet, it doesn't tell anything about the TCP stream. > A full TCP stream dump is required from the very first SYN to the very > last packet. > > Best regards, > Jozsef > - > E-mail : kadlec@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, kadlecsik.jozsef@xxxxxxxxxxxxx > PGP key : http://www.kfki.hu/~kadlec/pgp_public_key.txt > Address : Wigner Research Centre for Physics, Hungarian Academy of Sciences > H-1525 Budapest 114, POB. 49, Hungary -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe netfilter-devel" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
