Marek Szuba wrote:
Hello everyone, Following a suggestion I was given at the kernel Bugzilla I am forwarding this here. It has come to my attention lately that the only two ICMPv6 packet types which IPv6 conntrack allows at present to initiate new connections are "echo request" and "node information query"; all other types appearing in this context are considered invalid. In particular, this includes two neighbour-discovery types specified in RFC 2461: "router solicitation" and "neighbour solicitation" - meaning that if a server drops all INVALID packets early in its INPUT or OUTPUT chain of IPv6 netfilter's filter table, neither of the two can be received from clients. Given that router solicitation is used for stateless network autoconfiguration and neighbour solicitation is an IPv6 equivalent of ARP requests, having these two dropped can be quite bad - especially the latter, as it pretty much kills IPv6 over Ethernet. Steps to reproduce: 1. Obtain an IPv6 address assigned to an Ethernet interface of host A (link-local will do); 2. If necesssary, flush all ip6tables filter chains on host A and set their policies to ACCEPT; 3. From host B on the same Ethernet network, ping6 the aforementioned IP address to verify that everything works; 4. On host A, run something like "ip6tables -I INPUT 1 -m state --state INVALID -j DROP"; 5. Try to repeat step 3. This time the ping should fail and counters associated with the aforementioned rule should increment; 6. Repeat all the above using OUTPUT instead of INPUT, with the same final result. BTW. This problem was discovered and (hopefully) fixed collaboratively by Łukasz Stelmach <steelman@xxxxxxx> and myself, please attribute both of us should the patch make it into code repositories. Attaching a proposed solution to the problem - the enclosed patch adds "router solicitation" and "neighbour solicitation" to the list of ICMPv6 types IPv6 conntrack considers allowed to initiate new connections. Note that in principle "router advertisement" ICMPv6 packets could also be considered valid-new, as e.g. radvd periodically advertises its presence to the local network - as however it is not necessary to let this through as new to have things work (plus we aren't that big on broadcasting, even on supposedly-secure networks), the patch only adds solicitations to the list.
This patch seems fine to me. Yasuyuki, what do you think? -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe netfilter-devel" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
