There's a feature request for something similar on the xfs list, so I guess people are asking for it. That being said this really should not be a modifier but a separate operation, as the logic is very different from FALLOC_FL_ZERO_RANGE, similar to how plain prealloc, hole punch and zero range are different operations despite all of them resulting in reads of zeroes from the range. That will also make it more clear that for files or file systems that require out place writes this operation should fail instead of doing pointless multiple writes. Also please write a man page update clearly specifying the semantics, especially if this should work or not if there is no write zeroes offload in the hardware, or if that offload actually writes physical zeroes to the media or not. Btw, someone really should clean up the ext4 fallocate code to use helper adnd do the switch (mode & FALLOC_FL_MODE_MASK) { } and then use helpers for each mode whih will make these things a lot more obvious.