On 2020-01-26 at 21:12:02, Arend Van Spriel wrote: > On January 26, 2020 8:34:18 PM "brian m. carlson" > <sandals@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > > The 2018 13" MacBook Pro (MacBookPro15,2) has a Broadcom chip, the 4364. > > This chip appears to be specific to Apple and is not found in other > > hardware. > > > > Add this chip to the brcmfmac driver so that it can be recognized > > automatically. Note that the PCI device id is 4464 even though the chip > > is referred to as the 4364. > > So what is the plan regarding firmware. In the previous patch you mentioned > it can be copied from macos, but I am not sure if that is acceptable from > legal perspective. At least Linux distributions will have problem with that > for sure. I don't have a way to solve that problem. The firmware copyright presumably belongs to Broadcom and they would be able to grant that permission or ship firmware through the normal channels. As far as I know, this chip only comes with Apple systems, so users will acquire the system with macOS. I'm not aware of any legal reason that a user cannot copy the firmware from one location on their hard disk to another, so users will probably be able to legally use the firmware, even if it's not shipped with distros. There is also precedent for users acquiring firmware themselves via the b43 and b43legacy drivers, where users have to use a script to extract the firmware from other drivers. I wish I had a better answer to this, but I don't work for Broadcom or anyone associated with it and am just trying to get the Mac I was given for $DAYJOB to work with Linux. Perhaps since you do you'd be willing to ask them to release the firmware. The alternative is that the chip doesn't work at all (and can't be added via the new_id sysfs entry because of the rambase setting) and users have to compile a custom patched kernel to make their wireless card work at all. I'd really prefer to avoid that if possible, since it's a strictly worse experience in every way. -- brian m. carlson: Houston, Texas, US OpenPGP: https://keybase.io/bk2204
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: PGP signature
