Currently vduse does not seem to support configuration space writes (vduse_vdpa_set_config does nothing). Is there any plan to lift that limitation? I am aware of the discussions that took place here: https://patchwork.kernel.org/project/netdevbpf/patch/20210615141331.407-11-xieyongji@xxxxxxxxxxxxx/ Perhaps writes can be supported *selectively* without violating safety concerns expressed in the above email discussion? We are thinking of using vduse for hypervisor assisted virtio devices, which may need config write support and hence this question. To provide more details, we have a untrusted host that spins off a protected (confidential) guest VM on a Type-1 hypervisor (Gunyah). VMM in untrusted host leads to couple of issues: 1) Latency of (virtio) register access. VMM can take too long to respond with VCPU stalled all that while. I think vduse shares a similar concern, due to which it maintains a cache of configuratin registers inside kernel. 2) For PCI pass-through devices, we are concerned of letting VMM be in charge of emulating the complete configuration space (how can VM defend against invalid attributes presented for passthr devices)? I am aware of TDISP, but I think it may not be available for some of the devices on our platform. One option we are considering is for hypervisor to be in charge of virtio-PCI bus emulation, allowing only select devices (with recognized features) to be registered on the bus. VMM would need to register devices/features with hypervisor, which would verify it (as per some policy) and present them to VM on the virtio-PCI bus it would emulate. Protected VM should be shielded from invalid device configuration information that it may otherwise read from a compromised VMM. For virtio devices, the hypervisor would also service most register read/writes (to address concern #1), which implies it would need to cache a copy of the device configuration information (similar to vduse). We think vduse can be leveraged here to initialize the hypervisor cache of virtio registers. Basically have a vdpa-gunyah driver registered on the vdpa bus to which vduse devices are bound (rather than virtio-vdpa or vhost-vdpa). vdpa-gunyah driver can pull configuration information from vduse and pass that on to hypervisor. It will also help inject IRQ and pass on queue notifications (using hypervisor specific APIs). We will however likely need vduse to support configuration writes (guest VM updating configuration space, for ex: writing to 'events_clear' field in case of virtio-gpu). Would vduse maintainers be willing to accept config_write support for select devices/features (as long as the writes don't violate any safety concerns we may have)? Thanks vatsa
