[+cc ext4] Heads up on bug reports "Overlayfs fails to mount with ext4" On Sat, Jun 1, 2019 at 11:02 PM Marco Nelissen <marco.nelissen@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > According to the documentation, "The lower filesystem can be any filesystem > supported by Linux", however this appears to not actually be the case, since > using a vfat filesystem results in the mount command printing "mount: > wrong fs type, bad option, bad superblock on overlay, missing codepage or > helper program, or other error", with dmesg saying "overlayfs: filesystem on > '/boot' not supported". > (that's from ovl_mount_dir_noesc(), when ovl_dentry_weird() returns nonzero) Specifically for vfat it is weird because of dentry->d_flags & (DCACHE_OP_HASH | DCACHE_OP_COMPARE) because it is case insensitive. > > Should vfat be supported, or is the documentation wrong? If the documentation Documentation is wrong. > is wrong, what other filesystems are (not) supported? There are some special cases like /proc/sys and auto mount points, but the most common reason for unsupported lower is case insensitive filesystems and filesystems that support unicode character folding. Those filesystems MAY be case insensitive/unicode, depending on mkfs/mount options: adfs affs cifs efivarfs fat hfs hfsplus hpfs isofs isofs jfs xfs(*) ext4(**) (*) xfs case insensitive-ness feature is hidden from dcache (dcache is disabled), so overlayfs mount won't fail, but it may have unexpected behaviors. (**) ext4 supports per directory case insensitive and unicode folding since v5.2-rc1, if the filesystem was configured that way with mkfs/tune2fs. In this case, regardless of whether the lower dir is case insensitive or not, overlayfs mount will fail. I am guessing when people start using case insensitive enabled ext4, this problem is going to surface, because the same ext4 (e.g. root fs) could be used for samba export (case insensitive) and docker storage (overlayfs). I can think of some solutions for the private case of same case insensitive fs used for upper and lower, but let's see that the problem is real before discussing a solution. Ted, Gabriel, I didn't see that xfstests-bld was updated with case folding configs for ext4, nor that xfstests has any new case folding tests (saw some posted), so I guess that is still in the works (?). Did you happen to try out overlayfs/docker over a case insensitive enabled fs? I wonder if you could spare a few extra GCE instances per pre-release tests to run an overlay over ext4 config? I was nagging Darrick about this for a while and now I think the overlay/xfs config is being tested regularly. Beyond the fact that there are vast number of users using docker with overlay over ext4, overlayfs tends to find rare filesystem bugs because of its special use patterns (e.g. acd1d71598f7 "xfs: preserve i_rdev when recycling..."). Thanks, Amir.
