On Mon, 10 Apr 2017, James Bottomley wrote: > On Tue, 2017-04-11 at 08:52 +0900, Tejun Heo wrote: > [...] > > > Any comments? Any clues on how to make the delay "smarter" to > > > trigger only once during platform shutdown, but still trigger per > > > -device when doing per-device hotswapping ? > > > > So, if this is actually an issue, sure, we can try to work around; > > however, can we first confirm that this has any other consequences > > than a SMART counter being bumped up? I'm not sure how meaningful > > that is in itself. > > Seconded; especially as the proposed patch is way too invasive: we run It is a proof of concept thing. It even says so in the patch commit log, and in the cover text. I don't want an one second delay per device. I never proposed that, either. In fact, I *specifically* asked for something else in the paragraph you quoted. I would much prefer an one- or two-seconds delay per platform *power off*. And that's for platforms that do ACPI-like heavy-duty S3/S4/S5 like x86/x86-64. Opportunistic high-frequency suspend on mobile likely requires no such handling. The per-device delay would be needed only for hotplug removal (device delete), and that's just because some hardware powers down bays (like older thinkpads with ATA-compatible bays, and some industrial systems). -- Henrique Holschuh
