On 1/5/2012 12:52 AM, Greg KH wrote:
On Wed, Jan 04, 2012 at 04:31:36PM +0530, Pratyush Anand wrote:
Adding PCI mailing list too, as problem is coming only when MSI is enabled.
If I connect an PCIe analyzer, I see that at the time of issue
MRd(64) for 32 words has been issued with a wrong 64 bit address
from ethernet card to my RC.
In the normal course it always issues MRd(32) only.
Bug in your pcie firmware controller?
.
when you say "Bug in your pcie firmware controller?", is it RC's
software or EP's software?
Here I am pasting a part of analyzer log converted into text.
Packet(177940), is an upstream request for MSI. Whenever any device
writes at address 0x58A8F8, my PCIe RC considers it as MSI and generates
an interrupt. So I receive MSI interrupt correctly in my software. Also
MSI controller is correctly able to point me that the interrupt is from
ethernet card.
Now in Packet(178010), ethernet controller sends another upstream
request for MRd(64) of 32 dwords with Address(AFECEB87:A9D88B00).Since,
this address does not exist in my RC's world so, an UR is returned and
hence the problem occurs.
Now, question is, why ethernet card is generating inbound request with
such a wrong address. I have taken log of all the tx_desc->buffer_addr
programmed by software in function e1000_tx_queue. None of them is 64
bit or any invalid address.
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177916) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1475) Mem MWr(32)(10:00000) Length(4)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(2) Address(0EB00200) 1st BE(1111)
_______| Last BE(1111) Data(4 dwords) LCRC(0x44E0407C)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 549 544 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177918) Downstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(1475)
_______| CRC 16(0x0EB7) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 551 144 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177940) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1476) Mem MWr(32)(10:00000) Length(1)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(30) Address(0058A8F8) 1st BE(0011)
_______| Last BE(0000) Data(1 dword) LCRC(0xC21F32B6)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 588 544 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177942) Downstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(1476)
_______| CRC 16(0x69F5) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 590 088 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177946) Downstream 2.5(x1) TLP(309) Mem MRd(32)(00:00000) Length(1)
_______| RequesterID(002:00:0) Tag(19) Address(C01000C0) 1st BE(1111)
_______| Last BE(0000) LCRC(0x91BDA1F5) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 595 936 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177947) Upstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(309)
_______| CRC 16(0x25C6) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 596 368 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177950) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1477) Cpl CplD(10:01010) Length(1)
_______| RequesterID(002:00:0) Tag(19) CompleterID(003:00:0) Status(SC)
BCM(0)
_______| Byte Cnt(4) Lwr Addr(0x40) Data(1 dword) LCRC(0x8FE0D922)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 597 304 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177952) Downstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(1477)
_______| CRC 16(0xC8EE) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 598 840 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(177999) Downstream 2.5(x1) TLP(310) Mem MWr(32)(10:00000) Length(1)
_______| RequesterID(002:00:0) Tag(0) Address(C0103818) 1st BE(1111)
_______| Last BE(0000) Data(1 dword) LCRC(0xA898D9A1)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 687 936 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178001) Upstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(310)
_______| CRC 16(0xC6EA) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 688 384 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178004) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1478) Mem MRd(32)(00:00000) Length(4)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(4) Address(0EAFB990) 1st BE(1111)
_______| Last BE(1111) LCRC(0xB54722D2) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 689 312 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178006) Downstream 2.5(x1) TLP(311) Cpl CplD(10:01010) Length(4)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(4) CompleterID(002:00:0) Status(SC)
BCM(0)
_______| Byte Cnt(16) Lwr Addr(0x10) Data(4 dwords) LCRC(0xFE303776)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 690 288 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178007) Upstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(311)
_______| CRC 16(0x67F1) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 690 776 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178008) Downstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(1478)
_______| CRC 16(0x2BC2) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 690 824 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178010) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1479) Mem MRd(64)(01:00000) Length(32)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(11) Address(AFECEB87:A9D88B00) 1st
BE(1100)
_______| Last BE(0011) LCRC(0x6BE341C9) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 691 680 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178011) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1480) Mem MRd(64)(01:00000) Length(32)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(8) Address(AFECEB87:A9D88B7C) 1st
BE(1100)
_______| Last BE(0011) LCRC(0xAA5647BD) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 691 808 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178012) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1481) Mem MRd(64)(01:00000) Length(32)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(9) Address(AFECEB87:A9D88BF8) 1st
BE(1100)
_______| Last BE(0011) LCRC(0xEEB1F63F) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 692 120 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178013) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1482) Mem MRd(64)(01:00000) Length(32)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(10) Address(AFECEB87:A9D88C74) 1st
BE(1100)
_______| Last BE(0011) LCRC(0xA508142C) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 692 248 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178014) Downstream 2.5(x1) TLP(312) Cpl Cpl(00:01010) Length(0)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(11) CompleterID(002:00:0) Status(UR)-BAD
_______| BCM(0) Byte Cnt(124) Lwr Addr(0x02) LCRC(0xCE5540D2)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 692 328 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178015) Downstream 2.5(x1) TLP(313) Cpl Cpl(00:01010) Length(0)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(8) CompleterID(002:00:0) Status(UR)-BAD
_______| BCM(0) Byte Cnt(124) Lwr Addr(0x7E) LCRC(0x9FE2487D)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 692 456 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178016) Upstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(312)
_______| CRC 16(0x086E) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 692 760 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178017) Downstream 2.5(x1) TLP(314) Cpl Cpl(00:01010) Length(0)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(9) CompleterID(002:00:0) Status(UR)-BAD
_______| BCM(0) Byte Cnt(124) Lwr Addr(0x7A) LCRC(0x097BF4DE)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 692 776 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178018) Upstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(313)
_______| CRC 16(0xA975) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 692 888 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178019) Downstream 2.5(x1) TLP(315) Cpl Cpl(00:01010) Length(0)
_______| RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(10) CompleterID(002:00:0) Status(UR)-BAD
_______| BCM(0) Byte Cnt(124) Lwr Addr(0x76) LCRC(0x64BDF921)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 692 904 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178020) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1483) Msg Msg(01:10000)
_______| Msg Routing(To RC) Length(0) RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(31)
_______| Message Code(ERR_FATAL) LCRC(0xCDA53E96)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 693 184 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178021) Downstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(1482)
_______| CRC 16(0xA771) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 693 208 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178023) Upstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(314)
_______| CRC 16(0x4A59) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 693 280 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178024) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1484) Msg Msg(01:10000)
_______| Msg Routing(To RC) Length(0) RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(31)
_______| Message Code(ERR_FATAL) LCRC(0x86D9ACB6)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 693 312 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178025) Upstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(315)
_______| CRC 16(0xEB42) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 693 408 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178026) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1485) Msg Msg(01:10000)
_______| Msg Routing(To RC) Length(0) RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(31)
_______| Message Code(ERR_FATAL) LCRC(0xC5120A31)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 693 632 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178028) Upstream 2.5(x1) TLP(1486) Msg Msg(01:10000)
_______| Msg Routing(To RC) Length(0) RequesterID(003:00:0) Tag(31)
_______| Message Code(ERR_FATAL) LCRC(0x41499062)
_______| Time Stamp(0013 . 460 693 792 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
Packet(178029) Downstream 2.5(x1) DLLP ACK AckNak_Seq_Num(1486)
_______| CRC 16(0x231F) Time Stamp(0013 . 460 694 704 s)
_______|_______________________________________________________________________
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-pci" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
