On Thu, 2009-10-29 at 01:16 -0700, Eric W. Biederman wrote: > Yinghai Lu <yinghai@xxxxxxxxxx> writes: > > > > after closing look up the code, it looks it will not break your setup. > > > > 1. before the patches: > > a. when master card is inserted, all bridge in that card will get assigned with min_size > > b. when new cards is inserted to those slots in master card, will get assigned in the bridge size. > > > > 2. after the patches: v5 > > a. booted up, all leaf bridge mmio get clearred. > > b. when master card is inserted, all bridge in that card will get assigned with min_size, and master bridge will be sum of them > > c. when new cards is inserted to those slots in master card, will get assigned in the bridge size. > > > > can you check those two patches in your setup to verify it? > > I have a much simpler case I will break, as I tried something similar by accident. > > AMD cpu MCP55 with one pcie port setup as hotplug. > The system only has 2GB of RAM. So plenty of space for pcie devices. > > If the firmware assigns nothing and linux at boot time assigns the pci mmio space: > Reads from the bar of the hotplugged device work > Writes to the bar of the hotplugged device, cause further writes to go to lala land. > > So I had to have the firmware make the assignment, because only it knows the > details of the hidden AMD bar registers for each hypertransport chain etc. Do you mean you had to have firmware program a hot-added device, or just that firmware had to program the apertures of the root port that was present at boot, even though it had no devices below it? Firmware normally supplies ACPI _CRS information that tells us how it programmed the host bridge windows. On x86, Linux normally ignores that and just assumes a range based on memory size. If we paid attention to it (as with "pci=use_crs"), it's likely that we could do a better job of doing this setup. Or, of course, we could add a Linux driver that knows about "the hidden AMD bar registers." But I think that should be a last resort, for when firmware supplied incorrect _CRS information. > I don't see how throwing away the work that the firmware has done in > preallocation is something that we can afford to do in general if what > the firmware has done works for us. > > Eric -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-pci" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
