Hi, On 13/02/2019 01:41, Tony Lindgren wrote: > Hi, > > * Philipp Rossak <embed3d@xxxxxxxxx> [190212 22:25]: >> I'm looking now into that PVR SGX driver since a while. I already reworked >> that old "opensource" driver to work with a quite new kernel (4.16 or 4.17) >> [But that code got lost]. >> For the sunxi devices this was only a short coding session to get that >> running. For OMAP this might be easier/faster since the general linux >> situation is better. > > So a git repo that works for omaps and sunxi would be a good > start then :) > >> I'm not sure if we are able to provide a generic driver since there are >> different userspace versions that are only compatible with their own kernel >> driver. Not all compile flags for the kernel driver work with all userspace >> lib versions, at least on sunxi. Be aware that there are also different >> versions of those GPU ip cores and all have different features and bug >> fixes. > > No doubt it's a mess.. I'm only suggesting a generic driver that > manages standard Linux resources like regulators, clocks and > interrupts and provides 2d acceleration for sgx540 based on what > we already have at drivers/gpu/drm/gma500/accel_2d.c. The idea > being that it might then also make dealing with the rest of the > sgx blobs a bit easier hopefully. > >> If you reach a good state with that driver, I can try to port that to sunxi. >> Is there any good/cheap OMAP4/5 Devboard you can recommend? > > Hmm so the n900 folks have the sgx blobs working with recent > mainline kernels for sgx530 I believe, and Nikolaus is close to > having the sgx blobs working for sgx540. I may not be aware of > the current status though. Right, we have OpenGL ES 2.0 working with an older driver. > For a devboard with sgx540, you should be able to find one for > few tens of units for a used pandaboard-es for example or > somebody here might even have an old one to donate. If you feel > like playing with a phone, droid 4 xt894 is somewhat usable > with mainline kernels with pending patches for LCD and modem, > no idea what the sgx540 status on it might be. Pyra handheld > is not yet available except for prototypes. And then on > beagleboard-x15 there's sgx544, and beaglebone has sgx530 > FYI so that might not help if you need sgx540. Philip, I can offer to send a Droid4 your way if you're based in Europe. (If you're based in the US, it's probably cheaper to source one locally than to ship it -back- to the US). But I think the pandaboard ES should be a fine one too. (But I can recommend the droid4, it's fun) > > 1. A git repo that allows sgx blobs to work for various > SoCs with current mainline kernels Given that I've at least personally struggled to make the 3D blobs work - at all- on devices, this is would be my first aim. Also, if we have various devices that are working with some older kernel (hopefully with the most recent blob, but at least some blob), we could see where the differences are and resolve them, rather than work towards a generic shared driver where no device works yet, and we don't quite yet know why it doesn't work. Cheers, Merlijn
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
